In M/s.Seematti Silks Vs Ms.T.Beena [OP(TM).529/2023], the Madras High Court refused to expunge the registered trade mark “SEEMATTI” under Class 35 held by the respondent, ruling that a rectification petition initiated after decades of undisputed knowledge is statutorily barred by acquiescence under Section 33 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Presided over by Justice K. Kumaresh Babu, the single bench dismissed the original petition brought by Kumbakonam-based M/s. Seematti Silks against Kerala-based proprietor Ms. T. Beena, holding that continuous knowledge of an opposing party’s mark since at least 1994 without timely rectification proceedings permanently estops the later adopter from challenging the entry on the register absent compelling proof of initial bad faith.
| Disputed Subject Matter | Word Mark “SEEMATTI” (Registration No. 1839635 in Class 35 for retail textile services) |
|---|---|
| Plaintiff / Petitioner’s Case | M/s. Seematti Silks claimed bonafide adoption and continuous use since 1986 as a retail textile store, alleging that Respondent No. 1 obtained Class 35 registration by committing fraud upon the registry through false claims of usage dating back to 01.06.1910. |
| Defendant / Respondent’s Defense | Ms. T. Beena established prior adoption and continuous commercial use by her predecessors since 1910/1932, statutory registrations dating to 1963 (No. 215384), and contended that the petition was barred by Section 33 acquiescence, laches, and waiver due to Petitioner’s failure to challenge R1’s rights despite explicit notice in 1994. |
| Governing Law & Authorities | Sections 33, 47, and 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999; Ramdev Food Products (P) Ltd. v. Arvindbhai Rambhai (2006); Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. Scotch Whisky Assn (2008); Suzuki Parasrampuria Suitings (P) Ltd. v. Official Liquidator (2018). |
| Decisive Holding & Relief | Rectification petition dismissed. The High Court held that Respondent’s early registrations established bona fides, and Petitioner’s failure to seek rectification for over twenty-six years post-1994 notice constituted statutory acquiescence under Section 33. |
The Retail Textile Feud: Tracing the 1986 Adoption Against Pre-Existing 1963 Registrations
Looking to master Indian Trademark Law jurisprudence? Read our full Trademark Law Guide.
The conflict centers upon the trade mark “SEEMATTI”, widely recognized across Southern India for retail textile establishments. The Petitioner, M/s. Seematti Silks, operating a prominent retail textile store in Kumbakonam, Tamil Nadu, initiated rectification proceedings under Sections 47 and 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, seeking to expunge Registration No. 1839635 for the mark “SEEMATTI” under Class 35, registered in favor of Respondent No. 1, Ms. T. Beena.
Advocate Mr. Rajesh Ramanathan, arguing for the Petitioner, asserted that his client adopted the mark “SEEMATTI” in 1986, building commercial reputation over nearly four decades. The Petitioner argued that when it initially applied for registration on January 20, 1989, the predecessor of Respondent No. 1 filed an opposition notice in 1994. Although that opposition was abandoned, the Petitioner contended that Respondent No. 1 secured multiple registrations in 2009 under Class 35 by asserting an uncorroborated user claim dating back to June 1, 1910. The Petitioner highlighted that during examination of a companion application (No. 1839638), when required by the Registrar to substantiate the 1910 user claim, Respondent No. 1 amended its claimed date of use to February 16, 1995. This shifting evidentiary position, according to the Petitioner, demonstrated dishonesty and fraud on the Trade Marks Registry, rendering the registration void ab initio under Section 57.
Counsel Mr. Ramesh Ganapathy, appearing for Respondent No. 1, countered that her predecessors had operated retail textile stores under the name “SEEMATTI” since 1910 in Kerala, obtaining statutory trademark registrations as early as May 7, 1963 (Registration No. 215384 in Class 25) and May 7, 1977 (Registration No. 215385 in Class 24). Respondent No. 1 highlighted ongoing enforcement actions, including an infringement suit (O.S. No. 42 of 2018) before the VII Additional District and Sessions Court, Ernakulam, where an interim injunction against the Petitioner’s Thiruvarur outlet was sustained on appeal by the High Court of Kerala. Senior Panel Counsel Mr. A.R. Sakthivel represented the Registrar of Trademarks (Respondent No. 2).
The Statutory Bar: How Section 33 Acquiescence Extinguishes Rectification Claims
Where the proprietor of an earlier trade mark has acquiesced for a continuous period of five years in the use of a registered trade mark in India, being aware of that use, he shall no longer be entitled to apply for a declaration that the registration of the later trade mark is invalid, unless the registration of the later trade mark was not applied for in good faith.
The procedural defense mounted by Respondent No. 1 turned on the mandatory statutory bar embodied in Section 33 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Section 33 codifies the common law doctrine of acquiescence, establishing a strict five-year limitation window. If the proprietor of an earlier mark or a prior user standing by with actual or constructive knowledge permits another registered proprietor to continuously use their mark for five consecutive years, the right to seek cancellation or invalidation under Section 57 is extinguished.
The sole statutory mechanism available to bypass this five-year limitation bar is establishing that the impugned registration was applied for in bad faith. To defeat a defense of acquiescence, the burden rests entirely upon the applicant for rectification to adduce positive proof that the registration was secured through fraud or bad faith. Where bad faith is negated by pre-existing statutory registrations, the five-year statutory clock operates as an absolute bar to rectification remedies.
Evidentiary Forensics: Discrepancies in User Dates Versus Proof of Registry Fraud
The Petitioner attempted to substantiate its allegation of bad faith by pointing out discrepancies in the user dates claimed across Respondent No. 1’s various filings, specifically contrasting the 1910 claim with the amended 1995 date submitted under Application No. 1839638. In trademark prosecution, applicants frequently encounter registry objections under Section 11 when claiming long-standing historical user dates without complete documentary proof for every decade. Amending a user date during Registry examination under the Trade Marks Rules to facilitate registration does not automatically equate to fraud under Section 57 unless an intentional intent to deceive the Registry or usurp goodwill is proven through concrete forensic evidence.
Evidentiary standards for establishing historic user claims require corroboration through contemporaneous commercial records, such as historical GST or sales tax filings, audited balance sheets, municipal trade licenses, early newspaper advertisements, or physical ledger books. Where documentary evidence for ancient user claims is incomplete, registrants often amend their user statements to a date supported by verifiable invoices. Justice K. Kumaresh Babu rejected the Petitioner’s argument that these user-date amendments established bad faith, ruling that the presence of subsistence registrations dating back decades conclusively established the Respondent’s underlying bona fides. Assessing the evidentiary weight of these early registrations, the Court observed:
The benefit of the registered Trademark as early as in the year 1983, would be sufficient enough to hold that the adoption of the Trademark by the first respondent is only in good faith. When the claim of the petitioner that the registration was not in good faith, has not been substantiated, it is for this Court to answer the claim of the respondent as to whether the petition would be hit by the provisions of Section 33 of the Trademarks Act, 1999.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice K. Kumaresh Babu, Madras High Court
Because Respondent No. 1 had obtained statutory protection decades prior to the Petitioner’s entry into the marketplace in 1986, the bench held that the charge of bad faith collapsed, forcing the Court to evaluate the dispute strictly through the statutory bar of Section 33.
Doctrinal Battleground: Reconciling Section 28 Exclusivity, Section 34 Priority, and Section 33 Acquiescence
Indian trademark jurisprudence fundamentally adheres to a first-to-use common law regime. Under Section 34 of the Act, a prior user’s common law rights prevail over a subsequent registration granted under Section 28. This core doctrine, articulated by the Supreme Court in S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai (2016) 2 SCC 683 and Neon Laboratories Ltd. v. Medical Technologies Ltd. (2016) 2 SCC 672, protects marketplace equity accrued through actual commercial use. However, the decision in M/s.Seematti Silks highlights a critical statutory limitation: prior user rights under Section 34 cannot be asserted indefinitely in rectification proceedings if the party has acquiesced under Section 33.
The Court scrutinized the historical timeline, noting that when the Petitioner attempted to register “SEEMATTI” in 1989, Respondent No. 1’s predecessor formally opposed the application in 1994, asserting prior continuous use since 1932. This opposition put the Petitioner on direct, explicit notice of Respondent No. 1’s mark and legal claims. By allowing Respondent No. 1 to continue using and expanding its registered mark from 1994 until the filing of the rectification petition in September 2020, a span of over twenty-six years, the Petitioner was held to have fully acquiesced to Respondent No. 1’s rights.
The Court also addressed the doctrine of approbate and reprobate, citing Suzuki Parasrampuria Suitings (P) Ltd. v. Official Liquidator (2018) 10 SCC 707, Mind Gym Ltd. v. Mindgym Kids Library Pvt. Ltd. (2014 SCC OnLine Del 1240), and PEPS Industries (P) Ltd. v. Kuron Ltd. (2022 SCC OnLine Del 3275). These precedents establish that a litigant cannot take contradictory positions by claiming a mark is non-distinctive under Section 9 while simultaneously claiming exclusive acquired distinctiveness for itself. Reaffirming the principles laid down in Ramdev Food Products (P) Ltd. v. Arvindbhai Rambhai (2006) 8 SCC 726 and Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. Scotch Whisky Assn (2008) 10 SCC 723, the Court reinforced that acquiescence implies positive inaction. Sitting idle while a competitor builds commercial goodwill under a mark estops the silent party from later seeking invalidation. Delivering the binding ratio decidendi, Justice Kumaresh Babu held:
When the first respondent had claimed a prior use of the said Trademark as early as in the year 1994, it embodies upon the petitioner to have been diligent in verifying the use of the Trademark by the first respondent and ought to have taken necessary action against the first respondent for rectification of its registered Trademarks. Having failed to do so, and having allowed, the first respondent to continue to use a Trademark atleast from 1994, it would only mean that the petitioner had acquiesced himself for the use of the Trademark by the first respondent.
Hon’Performance Mr. Justice K. Kumaresh Babu, Madras High Court
Consequently, the bench held that the Petitioner was statutorily barred from challenging the entry on the register under Sections 47 and 57, making it unnecessary to adjudicate the remaining substantive issues on merits.
Interim Injunction Dynamics: Order XXXIX Review and Parallel Suit Strategy
The litigation history between the parties highlights the tactical interplay between civil infringement suits under Sections 134 and 135 and Registry rectification proceedings under Section 57. In parallel proceedings before the VII Additional District and Sessions Court, Ernakulam (O.S. No. 42 of 2018), Respondent No. 1 sought an interim injunction under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). While the trial court initially vacated an ex-parte restraint order, the High Court of Kerala reversed that decision on appeal on March 20, 2020, restoring the interim injunction against the Petitioner’s retail operations.
The Order XXXIX triple test requires courts to evaluate a prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury. The restoration of the interim injunction by the Kerala High Court demonstrated that Respondent No. 1 had established a strong prima facie case of statutory exclusivity. The Petitioner’s failure to disclose the Kerala High Court’s injunction order in its September 2020 rectification petition exposed it to allegations of un-clean hands and material suppression. When an infringer suffers an adverse interim order in a civil suit, attempting to launch a delayed rectification petition without challenging the senior registrant’s underlying title in a timely manner rarely overcomes the statutory bar of Section 33.
Key Precedents & Statutory Guidance
- Search recent High Court judgments in our Latest Indian IP Law Cases Directory.
- Examine core statutory doctrines in our Indian Trademark Law Guide.
- Procedural Breakdown: Customs IP Recordal in India & ICER Portal Procedures.
- Review nationwide litigation trends in our Monthly IP Law Roundup.
Litigation Strategy & Corporate Governance: Mitigating Statutory Acquiescence Exposure
The ruling in M/s.Seematti Silks v. Ms.T.Beena offers risk management lessons for IP litigators and corporate general counsel navigating brand enforcement in India.
Playbook for IP Litigators: Managing Opposition Notices and Timely Rectifications
- Track Notice Triggers: A formal opposition notice received during Registry examination serves as conclusive proof of actual knowledge. When an opposition is filed by a senior registrant, counsel must immediately evaluate whether to institute rectification proceedings against the opponent’s underlying registrations rather than simply abandoning the application.
- Avoid Abandonment Traps: Abandoning a trademark application after receiving an opposition without challenging the opponent’s title creates an adverse evidentiary trail. If the applicant continues using the mark commercially without challenging the opponent’s registrations within five years, Section 33 will bar subsequent rectification suits.
- Pleading Fraud under Section 57: Fraud or bad faith must be pleaded with strict precision. Minor administrative inconsistencies in claimed user dates during registry examination are insufficient to establish bad faith, particularly when the registrant holds valid prior registrations in allied classes.
Corporate Brand Governance: Guarding Against the Registration Illusion
- Off-Register Clearance Audits: In-house counsel must look beyond basic Registry searches before launching retail brand expansions. Conducting state-specific commercial surveillance, reviewing regional business directories, and auditing local distributor networks are essential to identify prior common-law users early.
- Proactive Coexistence or Acquisition Strategies: When a senior user or prior registrant is discovered during market expansion, reliance on geographic distance is risky. Corporate counsel should seek formal, recorded coexistence agreements under Section 12 (honest concurrent use) or pursue assignment of senior rights before substantial capital expenditure occurs.
- Document Management for Statutory Defense: Brand owners should maintain cryptographically verifiable records, including GST filings, e-way bills, and historical manufacturing batch records, to establish uninterrupted commercial use, successfully defeating bad-faith challenges under Section 33.
Case Details: M/s.Seematti Silks Vs Ms.T.Beena | Case Number: OP(TM).529/2023 | Court: Madras High Court | Date: 2026-11-12
Presiding Bench: Hon’ble THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE K.KUMARESH BABU
Appearances: For Petitioner(s): Mr.Rajesh Ramanathan | For Respondent(s): Mr.Ramesh Ganapathy for R1, Mr.A.R.Sakthivel SPCGSC for R2

