Skip to content
Subscribe
← Back
trademark

Madras HC Allows Additional Evidence in ‘Bharani’ Mark Dispute

7 min readUpdated November 18, 2026 Analysis
Madras HC Allows Additional Evidence in ‘Bharani’ Mark Dispute - Madras HC

Reading Tools

In M/S. K. MOHANASUNDARAM Vs M/S. BHARANI SILK CENTRE, [(TM) A.59/2026], the Madras High Court granted interlocutory relief permitting a trademark rectification petitioner to introduce supplementary documents post-completion of their oral evidence, holding that no legal prejudice is caused to the respondents prior to their witness testimony. Presiding over the Intellectual Property Division, Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji allowed four procedural applications ((TM) A Nos. 59, 60, 61, and 62 of 2026 in (T) OP (TM) Nos. 181, 182, 183, and 347 of 2023) subject to proof, relevance, and admissibility. The order balances the strict disclosure framework of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 against the imperative of securing a complete factual record in statutory rectification disputes.

Disputed Subject MatterRectification petitions under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 concerning the mark “Bharani” in Class 14 and associated commercial classes.
Plaintiff / Petitioner’s CaseM/s. K. Mohanasundaram (trading as Bharani Jewellers) sought leave to introduce Annexure-A supplementary documents post-evidence closure to establish continuous prior commercial adoption and goodwill.
Defendant / Respondent’s DefenseM/s. Bharani Silk Centre noted petitioner’s evidence was closed and earlier document applications were filed, but conceded lack of serious prejudice as respondent evidence had not commenced.
Governing Law & AuthoritiesSections 28, 34, 57, and 125, Trade Marks Act, 1999; Order XI, CPC (as amended by Commercial Courts Act, 2015); Madras High Court IPD Rules, 2022.
Decisive Holding & ReliefApplications (TM) A.59, 60, 61, and 62 of 2026 allowed. Supplementary documents received on record subject strictly to proof, relevance, and admissibility before Additional Master No. IV.

The Erode Commercial Conflict: Section 57 Rectification and Historical Mark Adoption

Struggling with Indian Trademark Law principles? Explore our complete Trademark Law Guide.

The substantive dispute arises from a commercial conflict in Erode, Tamil Nadu, where two trading entities asserted rights over the trading style “Bharani”. M/s. K. Mohanasundaram, trading as Bharani Jewellers at Nethaji Road, initiated original rectification petitions ((T) OP (TM) Nos. 181, 182, 183, and 347 of 2023) before the Intellectual Property Division of the Madras High Court. The petitions seek the expungement or alteration of entries registered by M/s. Bharani Silk Centre, a partnership firm at R.K.V. Road, Erode, on the Register of Trademarks maintained by the Deputy Registrar of Trademarks, Chennai.

Under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, an aggrieved person may petition for registry rectification where an entry is made without sufficient cause or wrongly remains on the register. In regional trade mark disputes, applicants frequently assert senior common law continuous use under Section 34 to invalidate a rival registration. To succeed, the petitioner carries a heavy burden to establish historical priority. While the petitioner had concluded primary witness examination, four procedural applications ((TM) A Nos. 59, 60, 61, and 62 of 2026) were filed seeking leave to introduce supplementary Annexure-A documents to reinforce their prior adoption claims.

Interlocutory Evidence under Commercial Courts Act 2015 and Madras High Court IPD Rules

The core procedural issue centered on the admissibility of late-stage documentary evidence in commercial IP suits. Following the enactment of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and the Madras High Court Intellectual Property Rights Division Rules, 2022, civil practice mandates strict procedural discipline. Under Order XI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), as amended for commercial disputes, litigants must produce all documents in their power or control along with initial pleadings. Subsequent production is prohibited absent leave of court upon establishing reasonable cause.

While this rule discourages piecemeal filings and trial delays, statutory rectification proceedings under Section 57 serve a broader public interest function: maintaining register purity. If compelling documentary evidence establishing prior continuous adoption is excluded on procedural technicalities, the court risks leaving an invalid mark on the public register, damaging commercial certainty and consumer protection.

Section 57, Trade Marks Act, 1999

Empowers the High Court or the Registrar, upon application by an aggrieved person, to cancel, vary, expunge, or rectify entries wrongly made or remaining on the Register of Trademarks to maintain statutory register purity.

Doctrinal Interplay: Section 28 Registration Privileges versus Section 34 Prior Common Law Rights

Analyzing late documentary submissions requires examining the statutory clash between Section 28 and Section 34 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Section 28(1) grants registered proprietors exclusive rights to use a mark and seek infringement remedies. However, Section 34 enacts an absolute statutory carve-out, preventing registered owners from interfering with continuous prior users whose adoption predates the registered mark’s registration or claimed user date.

Indian jurisprudence firmly establishes that common law prior use rights override formal statutory registration. In S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai (2016) 2 SCC 683, the Supreme Court ruled that passing off rights derived from prior continuous use prevail over statutory registration rights under Section 28. Similarly, in Neon Laboratories Ltd. v. Medical Technologies Ltd. (2016) 2 SCC 672, the Apex Court affirmed that a registered proprietor can be restrained by a prior continuous common law user. Because proving Section 34 priority requires establishing an unbroken commercial paper trail across extended timelines, admitting supplementary historical sales records, tax filings, and trade licenses under Annexure-A directly impacts the court’s ability to determine true priority.

Evidentiary Forensics and Prejudice Thresholds in Late-Stage Document Production

Justice P.B. Balaji evaluated the applications by assessing practical trial status rather than applying mechanical procedural barriers. The key inquiry was whether introducing additional evidence post-closure of the petitioner’s testimony inflicted legal prejudice on the respondent. In civil procedure, legal prejudice does not mean an opponent’s case is strengthened; it occurs when a party is deprived of a fair opportunity to inspect, cross-examine, or present rebuttal evidence.

Because the respondents had not yet entered the witness box, they retained full statutory opportunity to inspect the new documents, cross-examine the petitioner’s witnesses upon recall, and lead rebuttal testimony. Emphasizing this trial stage, the High Court observed:

The learned counsel for the respondents have no serious objection to the applications being allowed. It is stated that the petitioner’s side evidence has been completed. However, considering that the respondents are yet to enter the witness box, no prejudice would be caused to the respondents, if the applications are allowed.

Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji, Madras High Court

The court explicitly ensured that taking Annexure-A on record did not bypass evidentiary rigor. By subjecting admission to proof, relevance, and admissibility, the bench preserved the respondent’s right to challenge document execution and authenticity before the Additional Master. Delivering the operative ruling, the court held:

Accordingly, both the applications are allowed. The applicant / petitioner is permitted to produce additional documents, subject to proof, relevance, and admissibility. Post the matter before the learned Additional Master No.IV on 17.11.2026.

Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji, Madras High Court

This conditional allowance requires the petitioner to satisfy strict forensic proof standards. For electronic ledgers and GST portal printouts, compliance with Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) (formerly Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872) remains mandatory.

Section 57 Cancellation Strategy and Interlocutory Tactics for IP Practitioners

This ruling offers actionable interlocutory strategies for IP litigators managing commercial suits and rectification petitions:

  • Execute Early Evidentiary Audits: Counsel must conduct thorough documentary audits prior to closing chief affidavits to avoid successive Order XI applications and adverse cost consequences.
  • Target the Pre-Defense Window: Litigators seeking late document admission should move before the opposing party commences witness testimony, eliminating claims of irremediable trial prejudice.
  • Preserve Tripartite Objections: Responding counsel should ensure orders allowing late documents expressly preserve rights concerning proof, relevance, and admissibility for cross-examination.
  • Enforce BSA Certification Rules: During Master Court marking, practitioners must challenge uncertified electronic records and unauthenticated printouts under Section 63 BSA.
  • Align Parallel Suits and Rectifications: Coordinate documentary evidence across pending infringement suits and Section 57 actions to avoid conflicting user assertions.

Key Precedents & Statutory Guidance

Corporate Due Diligence Protocols for In-House Counsel and Brand Managers

For in-house legal teams, the dispute highlights that official registry searches are insufficient to guarantee commercial freedom to operate. Senior unregistered users possessing prior common law rights under Section 34 frequently operate in regional markets.

Corporate risk mitigation requires three proactive steps:

  1. Conduct Expanded Market Audits: Search state GST databases, regional business registries, trade association rolls, and e-commerce seller platforms alongside official registry searches.
  2. Maintain Digital Brand Archives: Establish secure archives for brand design collateral, physical invoices, advertisement logs, and tax filings with verifiable timestamps to defend against Section 57 petitions.
  3. Structure Regional Coexistence: Where senior regional users exist, evaluate structured coexistence agreements or assignments rather than relying solely on registration certificates.

Case Details: M/S. K. MOHANASUNDARAM Vs M/S. BHARANI SILK CENTRE, | Case Number: (TM) A.59/2026 | Court: Madras High Court | Date: 2026-11-11

Presiding Bench: Hon’ble THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI

Appearances: For Petitioner(s): Ms. S. Subashiny | For Respondent(s): Mr. A. Swaminathan for M/s. L.R. Swami & Co (R1), Mr. S. Janarthanan (R2)

Read the Official Judgment/Order Here

Written by

Adv. Koushik Chittella

IP Law Practitioner

Indian IP Law Trademark Patent Copyright

An Advocate enrolled on the rolls of the Bar Council of the State of Andhra Pradesh. What started as curiosity about how the law protects ideas, brands, inventions, and creative works gradually developed into a genuine passion for studying and explaining IP law, inspiring me to pursue a Masters degree (LL.M.) in Intellectual Property Rights (IPR).