Indian Courts
Monday, 16 November 2026
Rajkumar Theatres v. Wide Angle Creations, Madras HC
What Happened
This Week at a Glance • 2-Min Jump Guide
- COURTRajkumar Theatres v. Wide Angle Creations, Madras HC
- COURTSeematti Silks v. T. Beena, Madras HC
- REGISTRYKonkan Mango Growers Reject Proposed Geographical Indication Compromise with Valsad
- REGISTRYTelangana Prepares Five Traditional Crafts and Jewellery Products for Geographical Indication Registration
- GLOBALWIPO Reports Record 3.9 Million Global Patent Filings Powered by Growth in Asia
- GLOBALTurkey Registers Pakistan’s Basmati GI Across Four Provinces Altering Geographic Boundaries
In Rajkumar Theatres Pvt Ltd v. Wide Angle Creations and Others [OA.1114/2026], the plaintiff instituted a commercial copyright suit seeking an interim injunction to restrain the theatrical release and digital streaming of the sequel film Dhrishyam: The Conclusion. The dispute originated from a 2014 co-production and profit-sharing agreement concerning the Hindi remake of the original Malayalam movie. The plaintiff asserted that this agreement conferred exclusive rights over future sequels, prequels, and language adaptations across all media platforms. When the original producers and co-defendants initiated independent production and licensing of the sequel without the plaintiff’s participation, the plaintiff alleged copyright infringement under Section 51 of the Copyright Act, 1957.
Issue
Does a co-production and profit-sharing agreement for a single remake movie constitute an absolute assignment of future sequel and franchise rights under Sections 18 and 19 of the Copyright Act, 1957?
Ratio and Result
Justice P.B. Balaji refused the temporary injunction, holding that a commercial financial agreement conferring remake co-production rights does not convey an assignment of future derivative works. The Court held that a licensee cannot transfer rights exceeding those explicitly granted by the original statutory author under Section 19. Because the original creators retained underlying authorial rights, they remained fully entitled to exploit and license subsequent adaptations. Read full analysis: Rajkumar Theatres v. Wide Angle Creations Case Analysis.
Seematti Silks v. T. Beena, Madras HC
What Happened
In Seematti Silks v. Ms. T. Beena [OP(TM).529/2023], the petitioner sought rectification and cancellation under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 to remove the registered word mark SEEMATTI in Class 35 for textile retail services. The petitioner claimed commercial adoption and uninterrupted use of the mark in Kumbakonam since 1986, alleging that the respondent’s 2009 registration was obtained without bonafide entitlement. The respondent resisted the cancellation petition by showing that her predecessors established the textile business in 1910 and secured early trademark registrations dating back to 1955. The respondent proved that the petitioner had full awareness of her open commercial activities since at least 1994 without instituting legal action.
Issue
Is a trademark rectification petition under Section 57 barred by statutory acquiescence under Section 33 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 where the claimant tolerated open market use of the mark for over two decades?
Ratio and Result
Justice K. Kumaresh Babu dismissed the rectification petition, holding that continuous knowledge of an opposing party’s registered mark for more than five years without legal opposition creates a statutory bar under Section 33. The Court affirmed that the respondent established honest adoption rooted in historical commercial legacy, negating any bad faith. In the absence of fraudulent registration, long-standing acquiescence permanently disentitles a claimant from seeking statutory rectification. Read full analysis: Seematti Silks v. T. Beena Case Analysis.
TVS Motor Company Limited v. The Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs, Madras HC
What Happened
In TVS Motor Company Limited v. The Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs [CMA(PT).61/2024], the appellant challenged an administrative decision refusing Indian Patent Application No. 201841004638 titled “A Vehicle”. The claimed invention related to a two-wheeled saddle vehicle featuring a biometric fingerprint recognition unit mounted on the upper exterior surface of the fuel tank assembly. TVS argued that positioning the biometric unit away from the crowded handlebar area solved ergonomic restrictions and electrical routing complexities, demonstrating technical advancement over cited prior art references. The Patent Office rejected the application on the ground that the relocation constituted an obvious arrangement under Section 3(f) and lacked an inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja).
Issue
Does the structural relocation of a known biometric sensor onto the fuel tank surface of a two-wheeler satisfy the inventive step requirement under Section 2(1)(ja), or does it represent an unpatentable rearrangement under Section 3(f) of the Patents Act, 1970?
Ratio and Result
Justice K. Kumaresh Babu dismissed the appeal and confirmed the administrative refusal order. The Court held that merely shifting a known electrical sensing device to another convenient vehicle surface is a routine design selection that fails the inventive step test under Section 2(1)(ja). Because each individual component continues to function independently without producing any cooperative technical synergy, the subject matter falls squarely within the statutory prohibition of Section 3(f). Read full analysis: TVS Motor Company Limited v. The Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs Case Analysis.
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Dunar Foods Limited v. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP, Delhi HC
What Happened
In Dunar Foods Limited v. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP [C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM)-158/2024], the Delhi High Court heard cross-rectification petitions under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 concerning the trademark NAWAJISH for basmati rice under Class 30. Dunar Foods sought cancellation of AVJK Foods’ 2017 trademark registration, proving continuous commercial use and sales invoices dating back to 2007. AVJK Foods defended its mark by raising honest concurrent adoption and challenged Dunar Foods’ locus standi, pointing to ongoing Enforcement Directorate proceedings and corporate insolvency attachments against Dunar’s management.
Issue
Do regulatory attachment proceedings extinguish common law trademark property, and can a subsequent registration defeat established continuous prior user rights under Section 34 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
Ratio and Result
Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav ordered the removal of AVJK Foods’ registration from the Register while protecting Dunar Foods’ mark. The Court held that external regulatory or criminal investigations do not divest an enterprise of its proprietary intellectual property rights. Under Section 34, statutory rights conferred by registration under Section 28 are subordinate to the vested common law rights of a senior continuous user of an identical mark in identical trade channels. Read full analysis: Dunar Foods Limited v. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP Case Analysis.
Thursday, 19 November 2026
Varun Atulya Mafatlal v. Shree Vallabh Chandak, Bombay HC
What Happened
In Varun Atulya Mafatlal v. Shree Vallabh Chandak [COMMP/27/2024], the petitioner filed a commercial petition under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 seeking cancellation of the registration and assignment of the device marks SUNGRACE MAFATLAL in Classes 24 and 25. The petitioner claimed that historical family brand assets were unlawfully transferred through un-probated wills and defective registry recordals without statutory compliance. In an interlocutory application, the petitioner sought an ad interim injunction to stop the respondent from marketing textile goods under the disputed marks. The respondent opposed the injunction, relying on limitation under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, long-standing acquiescence, and continuous commercial investment as a bonafide purchaser for value.
Issue
Should the court grant an ad interim injunction restraining commercial exploitation of a registered mark during the pendency of a Section 57 rectification trial when substantial questions of limitation and testamentary inheritance are raised?
Ratio and Result
Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan admitted the rectification petition for trial but declined to grant an interim injunction. The Court held that an ongoing commercial venture holding registered title should not be halted at an interlocutory stage where complex issues of succession, limitation, and delay require full evidentiary proof. The balance of convenience favoured permitting the respondent to continue trading under the registered marks subject to maintenance of audited accounts. Read full analysis: Varun Atulya Mafatlal v. Shree Vallabh Chandak Case Analysis.
Omega SA v. Controller of Patents and Designs, Madras HC
What Happened
In Omega SA v. Controller of Patents and Designs [CMA(PT).40/2023], Swiss watchmaker Omega SA appealed under Section 117A of the Patents Act, 1970 against the refusal of Indian Patent Application No. 5932/CHE/2013. The patent application disclosed a method for mounting decorative precious stones onto components made of amorphous or partially amorphous metallic alloys used in luxury timepieces. The Controller rejected the application under Section 2(1)(ja), asserting that hot-pressing decorative components into metallic materials was obvious over three prior art documents. Omega argued that the Controller failed to evaluate the distinct metallurgical behavior of bulk metallic glasses within their supercooled liquid temperature zone and ignored corresponding patent grants issued by the USPTO and EPO.
Issue
Did the Controller of Patents err in issuing a summary rejection under Section 2(1)(ja) without providing a technical assessment of the claimed amorphous alloy material properties and international patent grants?
Ratio and Result
Justice K. Kumaresh Babu set aside the refusal order and directed the Patent Office to issue the patent grant within three weeks. The Court held that administrative patent rejections must provide clear technical reasoning addressing the specific operational characteristics of claimed materials. The Bench observed that while foreign grants are not binding on Indian patent examiners, parallel approvals by major patent offices provide persuasive evidence of inventive step that cannot be discarded through superficial examination. Read full analysis: Omega SA v. Controller of Patents and Designs Case Analysis.
Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd., Delhi HC
What Happened
In Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. and Others [CS(COMM)-484/2021], Spanish company Sotkon SP SLU filed an IP infringement suit in the Delhi High Court concerning underground waste container systems. The defendants filed an application under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking return of the plaint on the ground that the Delhi High Court lacked territorial jurisdiction. None of the defendants maintained an office, factory, or residence in Delhi. The plaintiff asserted jurisdiction based on the dynamic effect doctrine, arguing that commercial injury was experienced within the capital, and relied on a single quotation obtained by a private investigator.
Issue
Can an intellectual property plaintiff establish territorial jurisdiction under Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 by invoking the dynamic effect doctrine or through trap orders arranged by private investigators?
Ratio and Result
Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav ordered the return of the plaint under Order VII Rule 10 CPC for presentation before the appropriate court, firmly rejecting the dynamic effect doctrine. The Court ruled that artificial transactions orchestrated by private investigators amount to concocting jurisdiction and cannot satisfy statutory forum requirements. Establishing territorial jurisdiction requires demonstrable commercial engagement and purposeful availment targeting customers within the forum state. Read full analysis: Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. Case Analysis.
Friday, 20 November 2026
Dabur India Limited v. Anchor Consumer Products Pvt. Ltd., Delhi HC
What Happened
In Dabur India Limited v. Anchor Consumer Products Pvt. Ltd. [CS(COMM)-635/2026], Dabur filed a commercial suit before the Delhi High Court combining claims for registered trademark infringement, copyright infringement, and common law passing off regarding consumer goods packaging. Dabur claimed forum jurisdiction in Delhi under the special provisions of Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act, 1957 on the basis of its principal registered office. The defendant moved an application under Order VII Rule 10 CPC challenging the jurisdiction of the Court to entertain the passing off claim, arguing that both companies had subordinate offices in Mumbai and no sales or commercial events occurred in Delhi.
Issue
May a plaintiff join a common law passing off action with statutory trademark and copyright infringement claims in a court where jurisdiction exists solely under Section 134(2) and Section 62(2)?
Ratio and Result
Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav allowed the defendant’s objection and returned the plaint in respect of the passing off claim under Order VII Rule 10 CPC. The Court held that the expanded jurisdictional forum permitted under Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act and Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act is strictly limited to statutory infringement actions. A common law passing off claim remains governed by Section 20 CPC and cannot be joined without showing an independent cause of action or commercial sales within the territorial limits of the forum court. Read full analysis: Dabur India Limited v. Anchor Consumer Products Pvt. Ltd. Case Analysis.
Blink Digital India Private Limited v. Facebook India Online Services Private Limited, Bombay HC
What Happened
In Blink Digital India Private Limited v. Facebook India Online Services Private Limited [IAL/31469/2026], a digital marketing firm moved the Bombay High Court for an urgent interim mandatory injunction directing the platform intermediary to restore its suspended corporate accounts and social media handles. The platform had disabled the accounts following receipt of third-party intellectual property infringement complaints. The plaintiff contended that the unexpected shutdown caused irreparable harm to its business reputation, resulting in client departures and operational disruption without an opportunity to contest the allegations.
Issue
Does a commercial enterprise meet the high legal threshold required for an interim mandatory injunction compelling a social media intermediary to restore suspended user accounts pending trial?
Ratio and Result
The Bombay High Court denied the interim mandatory injunction, ruling that mandatory interlocutory relief requires an exceptional standard of proof demonstrating an unimpeachable legal right. The Court observed that online intermediaries acting under Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and Rule 3(1)(b) of the IT Rules, 2021 are legally obligated to take action upon receiving IP violation notices. Compelling an intermediary to reinstate blocked accounts before resolving underlying trademark or copyright claims would place the platform in direct conflict with its statutory due diligence obligations. Read full analysis: Blink Digital India Private Limited v. Facebook India Online Services Private Limited Case Analysis.
Deputy Commissioner of Tangail, Bangladesh v. West Bengal State Handloom Weavers Co-operative Society Ltd. & Ors., Madras HC
What Happened
The Deputy Commissioner of Tangail in Bangladesh, acting through the Bangladesh High Commission in New Delhi, filed a statutory rectification petition before the Madras High Court challenging the Indian Geographical Indication registration granted for Tangail Saree of Bengal. The Indian Geographical Indications Registry had issued the certificate in January 2024 to the West Bengal State Handloom Weavers Co-operative Society Limited based on historical migration of weaving communities to West Bengal. In response, the West Bengal cooperative filed an interim application seeking summary rejection of Bangladesh’s plea, contending that a foreign district authority does not qualify as an aggrieved person under Section 27 of the Geographical Indications of Goods Act, 1999.
Issue
Does a foreign administrative authority have legal standing as an aggrieved person under Section 27 of the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999 to maintain a statutory rectification petition before an Indian High Court?
Ratio and Result
Justice P.B. Balaji dismissed the cooperative’s application for summary rejection and held that Bangladesh’s rectification petition is maintainable. The Court ruled that cross-border geographical claims require a full trial and cannot be dismissed at a preliminary threshold. The Court directed both parties to file affidavits of admission and denial of documents and scheduled the dispute for final hearing in December. Read full analysis: Deputy Commissioner of Tangail, Bangladesh v. West Bengal State Handloom Weavers Co-operative Society Ltd. Case Analysis.
GI & Indian IP Registry News
Konkan Mango Growers Reject Proposed Geographical Indication Compromise with Valsad
Authorized custodians of the registered Konkan Hapus Geographical Indication tag formally rejected a compromise proposal from the Geographical Indications Registry to share the designation with mango growers from Valsad in Gujarat. The four registered holding bodies, including the Konkan Hapus Mango Growers and Sellers Cooperative Society and Dr. Balasaheb Sawant Konkan Agricultural University, affirmed that the Alphonso mango grown along Maharashtra’s 720-kilometer coastal belt possesses distinct agro-climatic characteristics that cannot be replicated outside the region.
The dispute escalated after Navsari Agricultural University and Gandhinagar University filed a competing application seeking the Hapus designation for fruit harvested in southern Gujarat. Konkan growers emphasized that the region produces over 40 percent of Maharashtra’s mango crop, generating 200 crore rupees in domestic sales and 80 crore rupees in exports. The grower associations resolved to contest the Gujarat petition before the registry, asserting that diluting the geographical boundary would mislead international consumers and harm local farming incomes.
Telangana Prepares Five Traditional Crafts and Jewellery Products for Geographical Indication Registration
The Telangana government reached the final stages of securing Geographical Indication recognition for five indigenous handicraft and jewellery traditions across the state. Field studies and historical documentation have been completed for Narayanpet jewellery making, Hyderabad pearls, Banjara tribal jewellery, Banjara needle craft, and Batik paintings. The initiatives aim to protect traditional artisan communities and establish legal branding against commercial imitations.
The state industries department is collaborating with community cooperatives to address technical queries from the Geographical Indications Registry in Chennai. In addition to the five advanced applications, administrative documentation is underway for regional agricultural varieties, including Armoor turmeric and Nalgonda chitti dosakai. Securing statutory protection is intended to expand organized market access and safeguard the intellectual property of local master craftspersons.
Assam Flags Off First Export Consignment of GI-Tagged Karbi Anglong Ginger to London
Assam Agriculture Minister Atul Bora flagged off the inaugural commercial export shipment of Geographical Indication tagged Karbi Anglong ginger to the United Kingdom from Guwahati. Organized through the Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority, the trial consignment of 1.2 metric tons marks the first time fresh organic ginger cultivated in the hill district of Karbi Anglong has been shipped directly to commercial buyers in London.
Karbi Anglong ginger received its Geographical Indication certification in 2015 for its high gingerol content and traditional organic cultivation methods practiced by tribal growers. State agricultural officials confirmed that regular supply shipments will follow if European retail markets respond favorably to the trial consignment. The export milestone establishes direct overseas market links for indigenous hill farmers and prevents uncertified intermediaries from trading on the crop’s regional reputation.
Controller General Extends Stakeholder Consultation on Draft Design Guidelines for GUIs and Icons
The Office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks issued an official notification extending the timeline for public consultation on the Draft Guidelines for Registration of Designs Relating to Graphical User Interfaces and Icons. In response to requests from industry associations and legal practitioners, the registry extended the deadline by one month, allowing stakeholders to submit formal recommendations and suggestions until 30 November 2026.
The proposed guidelines aim to modernize India’s design examination framework under the Designs Act, 2000 by establishing clear statutory standards for the protection of digital screen displays and application icons. Stakeholders have been directed to submit their representations to the Design Office and the Controller General via official email portals. The regulatory update seeks to align domestic design registration procedures with international technological advancements and emerging digital software products.
Also Read: Weekly Indian IP Law Digest: November 8 to 14, 2026 | Its IP Time
Key Precedents & Statutory Guidance
- Search recent High Court judgments in our Latest Indian IP Law Cases Directory.
- In-Depth Guide: Customs IP Recordal in India & ICER Portal Procedures.
- In-Depth Guide: Section 57 Trademark Rectification: Grounds, Jurisdiction & Procedure.
- Review nationwide litigation trends in our Latest Monthly IP Law Roundup.
International IP Updates
WIPO Reports Record 3.9 Million Global Patent Filings Powered by Growth in Asia
The World Intellectual Property Organization released its annual World Intellectual Property Indicators report, documenting a record 3.9 million patent applications filed globally in 2025. The data represents a six percent annual increase, marking the fastest global filing expansion recorded since 2016. WIPO Director General Daren Tang noted that enterprise investments in artificial intelligence and digital hardware drove filing activity despite ongoing macroeconomic fluctuations.
Asian patent offices accounted for 71.2 percent of all worldwide filings, reflecting a long-term geographical shift toward Asian research hubs. China led global activity with innovators submitting approximately 1.9 million patent applications, followed by the United States, Japan, and the Republic of Korea. India achieved a domestic milestone, recording a 37.5 percent increase in patent filings and exceeding 100,000 annual applications for the first time.
Turkey Registers Pakistan’s Basmati GI Across Four Provinces Altering Geographic Boundaries
The Turkish Patent and Trademark Office registered Pakistan’s basmati rice under the geographical indication category of Mahrec Isareti following an application by the Trade Development Authority of Pakistan. While earlier applications submitted by Pakistani authorities included territory in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, the finalized Turkish registration removed those disputed tracts, officially recognizing defined cultivation districts across Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and Balochistan.
The recognition of basmati production across four non-contiguous Pakistani provinces introduces fresh comparative context for ongoing Indian litigation regarding Madhya Pradesh’s claim to basmati GI status. Domestic opposition before the Madras High Court has historically resisted including 13 Madhya Pradesh districts by asserting that basmati is restricted to the traditional Indo-Gangetic Plains. Although foreign registrations do not create binding legal precedent in India, the multi-provincial Turkish boundary classification provides Madhya Pradesh growers with comparative agricultural arguments regarding climatic adaptation.
Dutch Court Rules BYD Fangchengbao SUV Infringes Jaguar Land Rover Defender Registered Design
The District Court of The Hague in the Netherlands ruled that Chinese automaker BYD infringed the registered Community design of Jaguar Land Rover’s Defender vehicle. The court found that the exterior body shape and stylistic features of BYD’s seven-seater Fangchengbao Ti7 sport utility vehicle replicate the characteristic aesthetic design protected by Jaguar Land Rover across the European Union.
The court issued an injunction prohibiting BYD from commercializing or selling the Ti7 model within the European Union, with the restraining order taking effect one week from judgment. The presiding judge clarified that the territorial scope of the Dutch injunction does not extend to the United Kingdom, where BYD had separately opened customer vehicle reservations. Jaguar Land Rover welcomed the ruling as judicial protection for automotive intellectual property, while BYD announced plans to appeal.
LeBron James Files Trademark Infringement Lawsuit Against Sports Betting App Over AI Likeness
Professional basketball player LeBron James filed a federal lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York against PlayVision Inc. and its founders. The complaint alleges trademark infringement and unauthorized misappropriation of publicity rights arising from the promotion of the defendants’ sports wagering research application, previously marketed under the name Bron.
The lawsuit focuses on video advertisements featuring an artificial intelligence generated avatar of James wearing a basketball jersey bearing his registered mark Bron alongside synthetic voice cloning. The complaint asserts that the unauthorized advertisements falsely depict James placing athletic bets, which violates National Basketball Association gambling prohibitions and interferes with his commercial endorsement agreements. James seeks an injunction against further marketing alongside compensatory and punitive damages.
Elon Musk’s xAI Petitions Federal Appeals Court to Block California AI Training Disclosure Statute
Artificial intelligence company xAI argued before the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit seeking an injunction to block enforcement of California Assembly Bill 2013. The statute, enacted to take effect in January 2026, mandates that commercial developers of generative artificial intelligence systems publish detailed public summaries describing the datasets used to train their foundational models.
Counsel for xAI argued that the disclosure requirements unconstitutionally compel commercial speech under the First Amendment and force technology firms to disclose trade secrets without compensation. The legal challenge reached the appellate court after a federal district judge in Los Angeles denied xAI’s motion for a preliminary injunction. A three-judge panel in San Francisco questioned whether the statutory transparency rules impose excessive compliance burdens or fall within legitimate state consumer protection powers.

