In Ms Rajkumar Theatres Pvt Ltd, Represented by its D Vs Wide Angle Creations and 6 others [OA.1114/2026], the Madras High Court refused to grant a temporary injunction restraining the worldwide exhibition and Over-The-Top (OTT) platform distribution of the Hindi feature film “Dhrishyam: The Conclusion”. Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji held that a commercial financial agreement conferring co-production and profit-sharing rights over a specific remake adaptation does not operate as an absolute statutory assignment of copyright under Section 19 of the Copyright Act, 1957, preserving the original authors’ statutory rights to license independent screenplay adaptations of their underlying literary works.
| Disputed Subject Matter | Exclusive Hindi remake, adaptation, prequel, and sequel exploitation rights to the Malayalam film franchise “Dhrishyam”, specifically the feature film “Dhrishyam: The Conclusion”. |
|---|---|
| Plaintiff / Petitioner’s Case | Claimed exclusive co-ownership and assignment of remake, dubbing, prequel, and sequel rights in Hindi under a 2014 agreement with the original licensee, asserting that original authors could not license a Hindi sequel to third parties. |
| Defendant / Respondent’s Defense | Asserted res judicata following the dismissal of a Section 9 arbitration application, argued that the 2014 contract was a commercial profit-sharing arrangement rather than a statutory copyright assignment, and demonstrated separate CBFC certification for an independent adaptation. |
| Governing Law & Authorities | Sections 13, 14, 18, 19, 51, and 55 of the Copyright Act, 1957; Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. |
| Decisive Holding & Relief | Temporary injunction against OTT and multi-platform distribution denied; court held plaintiff failed to establish a prima facie case, statutory title, or structural script copying. |
Chain of Title Friction and Interlocutory Battles Over the Dhrishyam Hindi Remake Rights
For foundational statutory analysis, consult our in-depth Copyright Law Guide.
The commercial dispute before the Commercial Division of the Madras High Court emerged from a complex multi-tiered chain of contracts regarding the Hindi derivative rights of the 2013 Malayalam feature film “Dhrishyam”. Produced by Aashirvad Cinema (Respondent No. 2) and directed by Jeethu Joseph (Respondent No. 3), the original film achieved pan-India commercial success. On December 22, 2013, Wide Angle Creations (Respondent No. 1) acquired exclusive rights from the producer and director to remake, dub, and adapt the film and its future sequels across North Indian languages, including Hindi.
On June 12, 2014, Respondent No. 1 executed an agreement with Ms Rajkumar Theatres Pvt Ltd (Plaintiff). Under this contract, the Plaintiff provided financial advances to co-produce and co-own the first Hindi remake, establishing a 50-50 net profit-sharing ratio. The contractual relationship became contentious following subsequent commercial transactions. On September 11, 2024, the Plaintiff and Respondent No. 1 assigned specific Hindi remake rights to the predecessor of Digital 18 Media Pvt Ltd (Respondent No. 4). However, on November 22, 2025, the original producer and director executed an independent assignment agreement valued at Rs 15 Crores with Panorama Studios (Respondent No. 5) to produce a distinct Hindi adaptation titled “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion”.
Senior Counsel Mr. K. Ravi, appearing for the Plaintiff, argued that the 2013 grant to Respondent No. 1 exhausted the authors’ underlying rights, preventing them from licensing any third-party sequel in Hindi. Conversely, Senior Counsel Mr. P.S. Raman for Respondent No. 4, Senior Counsel Mr. Sathish Parasaran for Respondents No. 2 and 3, and Counsel Mr. Manoj Menon for Respondent No. 5 contended that the Plaintiff acquired no underlying statutory copyright, but merely a commercial profit-sharing stake in a specific adaptation. Prior to instituting the commercial suit CS (Comm Div) No. 280 of 2026, the Plaintiff had sought an interim restraint against the theatrical release under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (OA No. 1050 of 2026), which was dismissed after contest. The Plaintiff then filed Original Application No. 1114 of 2026 within the suit, seeking OTT restraints, triggering preliminary defenses of res judicata, issue estoppel, and procedural abuse.
Deconstructive Analysis of Section 19 Statutory Assignments Versus Commercial Co-Production Financing
A commercial arrangement conferring profit-sharing rights in a specific film adaptation does not constitute a statutory assignment of underlying copyright under Section 19, leaving the author’s right to license independent adaptations of original literary works unencumbered.
The primary legal issue examined by the High Court centered on the characterization of the agreement dated June 12, 2014, executed between Respondent No. 1 and the Plaintiff. Under Indian copyright law, a valid assignment of copyright must strictly satisfy the statutory mandates of Section 19 of the Copyright Act, 1957. Section 19 requires that an assignment instrument must explicitly identify the specific rights assigned, their duration, territorial extent, and designated royalties. Furthermore, Section 13(4) establishes that copyright in a derivative cinematograph film exists independently of, and does not affect, the separate copyright in the underlying original literary, dramatic, or musical work.
Justice P.B. Balaji carefully scrutinized the preamble and substantive clauses of the 2014 contract to determine whether the transaction effected an absolute transfer of statutory copyright or merely created a commercial joint venture. The Bench observed that the transaction commenced as a financial loan extended by the Plaintiff to Respondent No. 1, which subsequently converted into a co-production profit-sharing mechanism for exploiting a single Hindi remake. Because the original authors had reserved their underlying statutory rights under Section 14(a), save for the specific license granted under the 2013 contract, Respondent No. 1 possessed no legal capacity to sub-assign broader authorial rights than it had legitimately acquired.
Addressing the fundamental character of the Plaintiff’s transaction, the Bench articulated a clear legal ratio distinguishing commercial profit-sharing arrangements from statutory copyright assignments:
As rightly contended by the learned counsel for the respondents, the agreement entered into between the applicant and the 1st respondent was not relating to any assignment of copyrights, but more a commercial exploitation of the Malayalam version of Dhrishyam in Hindi.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji, Madras High Court
Evidentiary Forensics: Censor Board Certification, Title Shifts, and Script Similarity Testing
In interlocutory copyright infringement actions involving cinematograph films, establishing a prima facie case demands concrete evidentiary proof of substantial similarity or structural script copying. The Plaintiff asserted that the Respondents acted in bad faith by initially marketing the project as “Dhrishyam 3” across social media channels, only to remove the numerical digit “3” and title the film “Dhrishyam: The Conclusion” four days after receiving notice of the Section 9 arbitration application. The Plaintiff contended that this nomenclature shift was a deliberate tactic designed to circumvent pre-existing sequel rights.
The Bench examined the documentary record, relying on the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) certificate dated September 28, 2026. The Censor Certificate officially registered the title as “Dhrishyam: The Conclusion”, certifying an independent screenplay adaptation that concluded the narrative arc rather than serving as a direct derivative sequel to the second Malayalam installment. Crucially, the Court highlighted a fatal evidentiary gap in the Plaintiff’s interlocutory strategy: despite the Hindi feature film completing its full theatrical run following its October 2, 2026 release, the Plaintiff presented no scene-by-scene comparison, script alignment, or thematic breakdown proving that the exhibited film copied protected expression from the 2013 original or the Plaintiff’s derivative work.
Evaluating the evidentiary record and the explicit terms of the contractual chain, the High Court recorded a decisive factual finding regarding the restricted scope of rights transferred to the Plaintiff:
On a conjoint reading of all the four agreements, it is significantly clear and evident that the rights that were given to the applicant/plaintiff by the 1st respondent was not the entirety of the rights vested with the 1st respondent under 1st respondent’s agreement with the producer and director of the original Malayalam version of Dhrishyam (1st version). The right to remake the original Malayalam version of Dhrishyam in Hindi alone was assigned by the 1st respondent to the plaintiff.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji, Madras High Court
Interlocutory Estoppel, Section 9 A&C Act Dismissals, and Order XXXIX Judicial Restraint
The procedural interplay between Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 formed another major pillar of the judgment. The High Court evaluated preliminary objections regarding res judicata and issue estoppel. The Court recognized that where an applicant moves a Section 9 court seeking identical interim restraint against film exhibition and suffers an adverse order after a full contest, failing to challenge that order through statutory appeal creates a formidable procedural barrier. Instituting a civil suit to re-agitate the same interlocutory relief under Order XXXIX CPC by merely narrowing the prayer from theatrical release to OTT exploitation borderlines on an abuse of judicial process.
Applying the settled three-pronged test under Order XXXIX CPC, the Bench held that the Plaintiff failed to satisfy any of the mandatory parameters. First, no prima facie case existed due to the absence of statutory title and failure to establish script copying. Second, the balance of convenience leaned heavily in favor of the Respondents, who had deployed massive commercial capital exceeding Rs 15 Crores to acquire and produce the adaptation. Restraining digital, satellite, and OTT streaming rights post-theatrical run would inflict severe financial disruption upon the distribution chain. Third, because the Plaintiff’s claimed right under the 2014 contract was fundamentally monetary, involving profit allocation, any alleged loss could be fully compensated through damages upon final decree, negating the element of irreparable injury.
Also Read: Novex Communications v. Campbell Resto: Bombay HC Grants Injunction
Key Precedents & Statutory Guidance
- Search recent High Court judgments in our Latest Indian IP Law Cases Directory.
- Examine core statutory doctrines in our Indian Copyright Law Guide.
- In-Depth Guide: Customs IP Recordal in India & ICER Portal Procedures.
- In-Depth Guide: Confidentiality Clubs in Indian IP Litigation (Delhi HC IPD Rule 19).
- Catch up in 2 minutes with our latest Weekly Indian IP Law Digest: November 15 to 21, 2026 | Its IP Time (or browse the Weekly IP Digest Archive).
- Review nationwide litigation trends in our Latest Monthly IP Law Roundup.
Strategic Intellectual Property Directives for Media In-House Counsel and Litigators
The ruling in Ms Rajkumar Theatres v. Wide Angle Creations provides imperative strategic directives for media litigators and corporate in-house counsel managing IP portfolios, film remakes, and derivative franchise acquisitions:
- Strict Compliance with Section 19 Statutory Drafting: In-house counsel must avoid relying on hybrid co-production contracts or financing agreements to claim underlying copyright ownership. If the commercial intention is to acquire exclusive derivative rights in future prequels, sequels, or spin-offs, the assignment deed must meticulously satisfy Section 19 of the Copyright Act, 1957 by explicitly defining assigned underlying works, future derivative rights, territorial limits, and specified royalty consideration.
- Mandatory Pre-Litigation Script Forensics: Litigators seeking interlocutory injunctions against cinematic works must go beyond title similarities or promotional marketing materials. Once a contested film has undergone public theatrical release, counsel must place detailed scene-by-scene script alignments, character arc comparisons, and structural plot analysis before the court to demonstrate substantial copying of protected expression under Section 51.
- Cohesive Forum Strategy and Interlocutory Estoppel Management: Media lawyers must carefully evaluate forum selection prior to initiating emergency litigation. Pursuing interlocutory injunctions under Section 9 of the Arbitration Act and suffering an unappealed dismissal severely compromises subsequent applications under Order XXXIX CPC. Interlocutory findings, while non-binding on final decree, create issue estoppel that prevents litigants from seeking identical remedies across parallel forums.
- Comprehensive Chain of Title Audits for Multi-Tiered Licenses: Corporate assignees acquiring adaptation rights from mid-chain licensees must perform rigorous legal due diligence on the original author’s retained underlying rights. A licensee cannot convey rights superior to those explicitly granted by the original statutory author, and reservation of underlying copyright by original creators leaves them fully empowered to license distinct adaptations to third parties.
Case Details: Ms Rajkumar Theatres Pvt Ltd, Represented by its D Vs Wide Angle Creations and 6 others | Neutral Citation: 2026:MHC:4563 | Case Number: OA.1114/2026 | Court: Madras High Court | Date: 2026-11-13
Presiding Bench: Hon’ble THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI

