Indian Courts
Friday, 13 November 2026
Sumangala Steel Private Limited v. Union Of India, Madras HC
What Happened
This Week at a Glance • 2-Min Jump Guide
- COURTSumangala Steel Private Limited v. Union Of India, Madras HC
- COURTM/S. K. Mohanasundaram v. M/S. Bharani Silk Centre, Madras HC
- REGISTRYCGPDTM Issues Cease-and-Desist Notice Prohibiting Commercial Scraping of Official IP Databases
- REGISTRYController General Announces Weekly Virtual Open House Sessions for Startups
- GLOBALElvis Presley Rights Holders and Eminem Publisher Sue Suno Over AI Music Training
- GLOBALMeta, TikTok, and Google Challenge Proposed Indonesian AI Copyright Law Revisions
In Sumangala Steel Private Limited Vs UNION OF INDIA [WP(IPD).36/2026], the Madras High Court partly allowed a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, ordering the administrative transfer of a pending trademark cancellation petition from the Trademarks Registry to the High Court Intellectual Property Division while explicitly refusing to summarily dismiss the cancellation action on maintainability grounds. The Single Bench of Hon’ble Mr. Balaji held that Rectification Petition No.
Issue
Does the contested commercial adoption create deceptive similarity and statutory infringement under the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
Ratio and Result
29 of 2026 to prevent multiplicity of proceedings and conflicting judicial decisions. However, the High Court firmly rejected the petitioner’s prayer to quash the rectification proceeding under extraordinary writ jurisdiction, holding that statutory challenges to maintainability under Sections 124 and 125 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 must be agitated through appropriate interlocutory applications within the pending commercial suit itself. Read full analysis: Sumangala Steel Private Limited v. Union Of India Case Analysis.
M/S. K. Mohanasundaram v. M/S. Bharani Silk Centre, Madras HC
What Happened
MOHANASUNDARAM Vs M/S. BHARANI SILK CENTRE, [(TM) A.59/2026], the Madras High Court granted interlocutory relief permitting a trademark rectification petitioner to introduce supplementary documents post-completion of their oral evidence, holding that no legal prejudice is caused to the respondents prior to their witness testimony. Presiding over the Intellectual Property Division, Hon’ble Mr.
Issue
Does the contested commercial adoption create deceptive similarity and statutory infringement under the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
Ratio and Result
59, 60, 61, and 62 of 2026 in (T) OP (TM) Nos. 181, 182, 183, and 347 of 2023) subject to proof, relevance, and admissibility. Read full analysis: M/S. K. Mohanasundaram v. M/S. Bharani Silk Centre, Case Analysis.
Smt. Mahalakshmi Ammal Charities v. M/S. Sri Narasus Coffee Company Private Limited, Madras HC
What Happened
MAHALAKSHMI AMMAL CHARITIES Vs M/S. SRI NARASUS COFFEE COMPANY PRIVATE LIMITED [(TM) A.56/2026], the Madras High Court granted interlocutory leave permitting the first respondent to adduce additional documentary evidence in transferred trademark rectification proceedings, holding that in the absence of willful default or dilatory tactics, procedural rigidity under commercial court rules must yield to substantive evidentiary completeness. Disputed Subject Matter Permissibility of adducing late documentary evidence in pending trademark rectification petitions seeking cancellation of registered marks under the ‘NARASU’S’ trade name across Class 29, Class 30, and allied product lines.
Issue
Does the contested commercial adoption create deceptive similarity and statutory infringement under the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
Ratio and Result
Mahalakshmi Ammal Charities opposed interlocutory applications (TM) A.56, 57 & 58 of 2026, contending that Respondent 1 failed to establish sufficient cause for non-production at the initial stage, making the applications belated and dilatory under commercial timelines. Defendant / Respondent’s Defense M/s. Read full analysis: Smt. Mahalakshmi Ammal Charities v. M/S. Sri Narasus Coffee Company Private Limited Case Analysis.
M.K. Mathivathanan (Deceased) v. M/S. Palson Enterprises, Madras HC
What Happened
The Procedural Imperative of Clean Chain of Title in Transferred IP Disputes Litigating intellectual property rights post-demise of an original mark owner frequently devolves into a procedural maze. When an original applicant or petitioner passes away mid-proceedings, counsel typically file blanket applications to substitute all surviving legal heirs to preserve the cause of action. Yet, leaving a multi-headed array of legal heirs on record when commercial rights have actually consolidated in a single entity creates procedural friction.
Issue
Does the contested commercial adoption create deceptive similarity and statutory infringement under the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
Ratio and Result
Palson Enterprises , the Madras High Court offered a clean procedural solution to this common problem. Balaji approved the striking off of non-prosecuting legal heirs following a private family arrangement, allowing a single assignee-proprietor to carry forward the trademark litigation alone. Read full analysis: M.K. Mathivathanan (Deceased) v. M/S. Palson Enterprises, Case Analysis.
Malhotra International v. Rohan Malhotra, Calcutta HC
What Happened
Strategic Implications of Pending Rectification in ‘PANAMA’ Trademark Feuds Can a defendant neutralize an immediate court injunction simply by challenging a registered trademark at the Registry? The Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court addressed this contentious commercial question in MALHOTRA INTERNATIONAL PRIVATE LIMITED vs. ROHAN MALHOTRA AND ORS.
Issue
Does the contested commercial adoption create deceptive similarity and statutory infringement under the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
Ratio and Result
Decided on November 13, 2026, the ruling clarifies how pending cancellation applications interact with emergency judicial remedies. Brand owners often assume statutory registration guarantees instant injunctive relief. Read full analysis: Malhotra International v. Rohan Malhotra Case Analysis.
Bull Agro Implements v. Ashlyn Antony, Madras HC
What Happened
Agricultural machinery manufacturer M/s. Bull Agro Implements filed an original petition before the Intellectual Property Division of the Madras High Court seeking revocation of Indian Patent No. 458805 granted to Ashlyn Antony for a Baler for tying round blade using twine. The petitioner instituted the revocation proceedings under Section 64(1) of the Patents Act, 1970 after receiving an infringement cease and desist notice from the patentee. The petitioner alleged that the tying mechanism lacked novelty across twelve cited prior art documents and was not commercially worked in India. The patentee defended the patent as an integrated mechanical combination comprising a link plate chain drive and a density-triggered cutting mechanism.
Issue
Can a granted combination patent be revoked for obviousness through piecemeal mosaicing of disparate prior arts without expert evidence under Order XIX CPC, and does commercial non-working constitute a ground for revocation under Section 64 of the Patents Act, 1970?
Ratio and Result
Justice P.B. Balaji dismissed the revocation petition in its entirety and upheld the validity of Indian Patent No. 458805. The Court held that an integrated mechanical combination cannot be invalidated through hindsight mosaicing of disparate prior art references when no teaching in the cited literature would lead a person skilled in the art to the claimed arrangement. The Court ruled that advocate arguments without expert affidavits under Order XIX of the Code of Civil Procedure cannot displace the statutory presumption of patent validity. The Court further clarified that commercial non-working under Section 146(2) falls under compulsory licensing provisions rather than revocation under Section 64. Read full analysis: Bull Agro Implements v. Ashlyn Antony Case Analysis.
GI & Indian IP Registry News
CGPDTM Issues Cease-and-Desist Notice Prohibiting Commercial Scraping of Official IP Databases
The Office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks issued Public Notice No. CG/F/CGPDTM/DL-10/5055 on 10 November 2026 to prohibit the unauthorized commercial exploitation of its digital resources. The registry observed that legal-tech platforms and commercial entities have been scraping, rebranding, and selling official government materials. The targeted databases include the IP Lex judicial repository, statutory registers, search databases, and official patent and trademark journals published on the IP India website.
The Controller General affirmed that all official databases, compilations, and digital arrangements constitute protected government work owned by the Government of India, with the terms Intellectual Property India, IP India, IP Lex, and the official emblem serving as official identifiers. The notice gave all infringing operators a strict seven-day deadline to cease commercial activities and remove offending content. Failure to comply will invite civil and criminal prosecution under intellectual property statutes and information technology laws. Bona fide non-commercial research with proper attribution remains permissible.
Controller General Announces Weekly Virtual Open House Sessions for Startups
The Office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks issued Public Notice No. CG/F/CGPDTM/DL-11/5056 on 11 November 2026 to establish weekly Open House Sessions designed to assist startups with intellectual property procedures. The interactive sessions will take place every Thursday between 3:30 PM and 4:30 PM IST via Cisco WebEx, with meeting links hosted directly on the IP India portal. The initiative establishes a direct channel for startup founders to engage with registry examiners and senior officers to resolve procedural queries concerning application filing and examination procedures.
The registry structured the monthly calendar by technical domains to ensure targeted guidance. The first Thursday of each month covers patent applications in biotechnology and allied fields, while the second Thursday addresses electrical systems and computer science. The third Thursday focuses on chemical inventions, and the fourth Thursday covers mechanical engineering patents alongside trademark and design registration matters. The program seeks to facilitate direct interaction between regulatory officials and emerging enterprises across the country.
Six Registered Geographical Indications Place Jammu and Kashmir’s Udhampur on Cultural Map
Jammu and Kashmir’s Udhampur parliamentary constituency has secured statutory recognition for six distinctive regional products under the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999. Union Minister of State Dr. Jitendra Singh confirmed that coordinated administrative initiatives helped document and register traditional crafts and agricultural commodities across different assembly segments within the constituency, establishing legal protection for regional artisans and agricultural producers.
The six certified items encompass celebrated handicrafts and agricultural goods originating from distinct districts. Kathua district contributes historical Basohli miniature paintings, which date to the seventeenth century, alongside traditional Basohli Pashmina woollen textiles. Doda district features Bhaderwah Rajmash, a premium kidney bean variety cultivated in the Bhaderwah valley. Ramban district accounts for two agricultural products, namely Ramban Sulai Honey harvested from wild basil blooms and Ramban Anardana produced from sun-dried wild pomegranate seeds. The certification list also includes Udhampur Kaladi, a traditional ripened cheese popular throughout Jammu. The registrations grant exclusive branding rights and protect local producers from market adulteration.
Goa Files Geographical Indication Application for Traditional Handmade Crochet Craft
The Goa Government, through its Department of Science, Technology and Waste Management, filed a formal application on 6 November 2026 seeking Geographical Indication registration for Goa Crochet Crafts. The filing seeks statutory recognition and market protection for a traditional handicraft practiced by women artisans across Goan villages. Artisans craft delicate lace fabrics, tablecloths, and ornamental apparel by hand using a single crochet hook and fine cotton thread, utilizing distinct floral and geometric motifs passed down through domestic practice.
The craft shares deep connections with Goan social customs, particularly Catholic wedding traditions where handmade crochet items form a central part of the bridal trousseau, known locally as dene. The Industrial Handicrafts and Handloom Cooperative Society, established in 1980, has organized women into cooperatives to market their wares commercially. Securing the Geographical Indication tag is intended to preserve historical fabrication methods and support rural artisan livelihoods.
Nagaland Identifies Twenty-Four Traditional Crafts and Textiles for Geographical Indication Registration
The North Eastern Handicrafts and Handlooms Development Corporation, in collaboration with the Ministry of Development of North Eastern Region, convened a stakeholder consultation in Dimapur on traditional crafts and handloom products of Nagaland. Officials announced during the meeting that 24 traditional indigenous products have been selected across the state for Geographical Indication registration. The initiative aims to document ancestral craft traditions and file formal applications with the Geographical Indications Registry.
The identified products include Pochury textiles and shawls, Zeliang textiles, Sumi shawls and fabrics, Ao textiles, and Tikhir traditional jewellery and garments. Respective tribal apex councils, including the Pochury Hoho, Zeliang People’s Organization, Sumi Hoho, Ao Senden, and Tikhir Council, will act as the registered applicant bodies. Officials stated that specialized legal and technical consultants have been engaged to assist tribal councils with historical documentation and statutory filing procedures to safeguard regional ownership and prevent commercial misrepresentation.
Also Read: Weekly Indian IP Law Digest: November 15 to 21, 2026 | Its IP Time
Key Precedents & Statutory Guidance
- Search recent High Court judgments in our Latest Indian IP Law Cases Directory.
- In-Depth Guide: Customs IP Recordal in India & ICER Portal Procedures.
- In-Depth Guide: Section 57 Trademark Rectification: Grounds, Jurisdiction & Procedure.
- Catch up in 2 minutes with our latest Weekly Indian IP Law Digest: November 15 to 21, 2026 | Its IP Time (or browse the Weekly IP Digest Archive).
- Review nationwide litigation trends in our Latest Monthly IP Law Roundup.
International IP Updates
Elvis Presley Rights Holders and Eminem Publisher Sue Suno Over AI Music Training
Rights holders representing the musical legacies of Elvis Presley and Eminem filed separate copyright infringement lawsuits against artificial intelligence music generator Suno in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. Music publishers Authentic Brands Group and Raleigh Music Publishing alleged that Suno copied 859 Elvis compositions without permission to train its generative models. In a companion lawsuit, independent publisher Eight Mile Style alleged that Suno unauthorizedly ingested 269 of Eminem’s protected musical compositions, including Lose Yourself and Stan, to generate sound-alike rap audio.
The Presley complaint marks one of the earliest major federal tests of Tennessee’s 2024 Ensuring Likeness, Voice and Image Security Act, known as the ELVIS Act, which protects individual performers from unauthorized commercial vocal cloning. The complaints allege that Suno circumvented digital encryption to rip master audio from online platforms and harvested lyrics from third-party databases. The publishers contend that Suno’s prompt safeguards are ineffective, permitting users to generate commercial audio tracks that copy the distinct vocal styles and phrasing of both iconic artists without authorization.
Meta, TikTok, and Google Challenge Proposed Indonesian AI Copyright Law Revisions
Technology companies Meta, TikTok, and Google joined forces during parliamentary hearings in Jakarta to oppose draft revisions to Indonesia’s copyright statutes governing artificial intelligence. The proposed legislation would make Indonesia the first Southeast Asian nation to integrate mandatory artificial intelligence training regulations into its copyright regime. Under the draft bill, developers would be required to obtain prior consent from copyright owners and pay statutory royalties before using copyrighted texts and audiovisual content to train commercial models.
The draft revisions also introduce payment requirements obligating internet platforms to compensate domestic news publishers for displaying preview links or text snippets. Representatives from Google and Meta argued before lawmakers that mandatory snippet fees would restrict public access to information and reduce referral traffic to news websites. TikTok urged the Indonesian parliament to narrow disclosure mandates by distinguishing between synthetic media and content created with ordinary artificial intelligence assistance.
USPTO Returns Patent Review Institution Authority to Patent Trial and Appeal Board Panels
United States Patent and Trademark Office Director John Squires and General Counsel John Duffy issued an administrative memorandum transferring merits-based institution authority for post-grant patent challenges back to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. The directive, taking effect on 16 November 2026, modifies a centralized review policy established in October 2025 that concentrated institution determinations within the executive office of the agency director.
Under the revised procedure, the USPTO Director retains initial gatekeeping authority to screen petitions on non-merits policy grounds, including discretionary denial doctrines and procedural timing rules. Petitions that clear initial screening are then referred to three-judge panels of the administrative tribunal to evaluate the substantive merits of the patentability challenge. To ensure procedural impartiality, the agency established that any trial instituted on the merits will be heard and decided by an entirely separate panel of administrative patent judges.
Anthropic Sued in Delaware Federal Court for Infringing Neural Network Patents
Patent holding entity Flinn Artificial Intelligence Technologies LLC filed a patent infringement complaint against Anthropic in the United States District Court for the District of Delaware. The lawsuit alleges that Anthropic’s Claude generative models willfully infringe five United States patents covering foundational attention-based neural network architectures. The asserted patents claim priority dates from 2015 and 2016 and name computer scientists Steven Flinn and Naomi Felina Moneypenny as the inventors.
The plaintiff alleges that Anthropic builds its large language models using proprietary attention algorithms and transformer mechanisms disclosed in the asserted patent specifications without securing a commercial patent license. The legal action, instituted ahead of Anthropic’s planned initial public offering, seeks compensatory damages and ongoing licensing royalties alongside findings of willful infringement.
Software Provider Sues Anthropic in Virginia Federal Court Over Mythos Trademark
Virginia-based enterprise software provider Global Printing, Inc. filed a trademark infringement lawsuit against Anthropic in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia on 13 November 2026. The plaintiff, which operates a donor-relations and software platform under the registered brand MYTHOS, alleges that Anthropic’s commercial use of the name Mythos for its artificial intelligence model infringes its registered trademark rights and creates substantial consumer confusion in the software market.
The lawsuit follows an administrative ruling in October by the United States Patent and Trademark Office that refused Anthropic’s federal trademark application for Claude Mythos due to a likelihood of confusion with the plaintiff’s senior registration. Global Printing seeks an injunction prohibiting Anthropic from marketing or distributing software under the Mythos name, alongside monetary damages for trademark infringement and unfair competition. An Anthropic spokesperson stated that the company disputes the allegations and intends to contest the suit.

