Skip to content
Subscribe
← Back
Weekly IP Digest

Weekly Indian IP Law Digest: November 1 to 7, 2026 | Its IP Time

30 min read In-depth analysis
Weekly Indian IP Law Digest

Indian Courts

Monday, 2 November 2026

Ramesh Bishnoi v. The Registrar of Trade Marks, Madras HC

What Happened

This Week at a Glance • 2-Min Jump Guide

Share briefing:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Ramesh Bishnoi filed a statutory appeal before the Intellectual Property Division of the Madras High Court challenging an administrative order passed by the Trade Marks Registry. The appellant had applied for registration of the device mark ELITE under Application No. 4869008 in Class 11 covering heating, cooking, and cooling apparatus. The Examiner refused the mark under Section 11(1) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, citing prior conflicting trademark registrations containing identical word elements. The appellant argued that the cited conflicting marks were either officially abandoned by their proprietors or removed from the Register due to non-renewal.

Issue

Did the Registrar of Trade Marks commit a procedural error by refusing registration under Section 11(1) without verifying whether the cited conflicting marks were legally subsisting on the Register?

Ratio and Result

Justice P.B. Balaji set aside the refusal order and remitted the application back to the Trade Marks Registry for fresh consideration. The Court held that relative grounds of refusal under Section 11(1) cannot operate against citations that are abandoned, lapsed, or removed from the Register. The Registry was directed to afford the appellant an opportunity of hearing and re-examine the mark within two months. Read full analysis: Ramesh Bishnoi v. The Registrar of Trade Marks Case Analysis.

Kobelco Compressors Corporation v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, Madras HC

What Happened

Japanese industrial manufacturer Kobelco Compressors Corporation preferred an appeal under Section 117A of the Patents Act, 1970 before the Madras High Court challenging the refusal of Indian Patent Application No. 201747012920. The invention claimed an advanced sound insulating package for compressor units designed to reduce mechanical noise and maintain thermal dissipation. The Assistant Controller rejected the application on the ground of lacking inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja), combining teachings from two prior art references, D1 and D2. Kobelco contended that the Controller engaged in impermissible hindsight analysis without demonstrating how a person skilled in the art would combine the cited documents.

Issue

Did the Patent Office err in rejecting the patent application for lack of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) by combining unrelated prior art references through hindsight reconstruction?

Ratio and Result

Justice P.B. Balaji set aside the rejection order and remanded the application for de novo consideration by a different patent controller. The Court held that an inventive step objection requires concrete technical reasons showing why a skilled person would combine separate prior disclosures. The Court directed that the fresh examination be concluded within four months without relying on hindsight bias. Read full analysis: Kobelco Compressors Corporation v. Assistant Controller Case Analysis.

Galaxy Health Insurance Company Limited v. Hostinger Operations UAB, Madras HC

What Happened

Galaxy Health Insurance Company Limited instituted a commercial intellectual property suit before the Madras High Court against European domain registrar Hostinger Operations UAB. The plaintiff discovered that cyber squatters were registering fraudulent domain names incorporating its registered trademark GALAXY HEALTH to run deceptive phishing portals. Galaxy Health sought permanent injunctive relief and mandatory directions to restrain domain name registrars from activating deceptive domain variants. During the proceedings, Hostinger submitted a comprehensive formal undertaking agreeing to implement automated technical filters and maintain responsive abuse-reporting mechanisms.

Issue

Can a court bind an offshore domain name registrar through formal undertakings to proactively prevent the automated creation of deceptive domain names that infringe registered trademarks?

Ratio and Result

Justice P.B. Balaji decreed the suit in terms of the joint memo of compromise and recorded Hostinger’s formal undertaking. The Court bound the registrar to lock and suspend any domain containing the plaintiff’s mark within twenty-four hours of written notification. Hostinger was also directed to furnish registrant contact details to assist law enforcement agencies. Read full analysis: Galaxy Health Insurance Company Limited v. Hostinger Operations UAB Case Analysis.

Unilever PLC & Anr. v. Manji Patel & Anr., Bombay HC

What Happened

Unilever PLC and Hindustan Unilever Limited filed a commercial intellectual property suit before the Bombay High Court alleging large-scale trademark and copyright infringement. The plaintiffs asserted proprietary rights over the marks GLOW & LOVELY and FAIR & LOVELY in Class 3 for skincare creams and cosmetic goods. Court-appointed commissioners raided premises associated with Defendant No. 2, Tarun Kumar, seizing thousands of counterfeit cosmetic containers bearing identical trade dress. Defendant No. 2 subsequently approached the plaintiffs and executed bilateral Consent Terms to resolve the litigation amicably.

Issue

Can the High Court decree a commercial infringement suit under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure against an individual counterfeiter while keeping proceedings alive against co-defendants?

Ratio and Result

Justice Madhav J. Jamdar accepted the Consent Terms and passed a partial decree of permanent injunction against Defendant No. 2. The Court restrained the defendant from manufacturing, distributing, or selling any cosmetics under the plaintiffs’ registered marks and packaging. Defendant No. 2 undertook to hand over all seized counterfeit stock for destruction and pay agreed legal costs. Read full analysis: Unilever PLC & Anr. v. Manji Patel & Anr. Case Analysis.

Godpower Media Private Limited v. John Does & Ors., Bombay HC

What Happened

Godpower Media Private Limited approached the Bombay High Court by filing a quia timet commercial copyright suit to protect its unreleased cinematograph film. The plaintiff demonstrated significant financial investments in theatrical production and distribution agreements across domestic and overseas territories. Apprehending that rogue pirate portals and file-sharing networks would illegally leak digital copies upon theatrical release, the production house sought dynamic blocking orders. The plaintiff named twenty-nine rogue platforms alongside unidentified John Doe operators.

Issue

Is a copyright owner entitled to an ex-parte dynamic injunction under Section 55 of the Copyright Act, 1957 to prevent imminent piracy of an unreleased cinematograph film across rogue online platforms?

Ratio and Result

Justice Kamal Khata granted an ad-interim ex-parte dynamic injunction restraining all named and unnamed defendants from hosting, streaming, or distributing the film. The Court directed internet service providers to block access to the rogue domains within twenty-four hours. Domain name registrars were ordered to suspend the infringing websites and disclose the identity of their registrants. Read full analysis: Godpower Media Private Limited v. John Does & Ors. Case Analysis.

Universal City Studios LLC & Ors. v. Dembed2.com & Ors., Delhi HC

What Happened

A consortium of leading international entertainment studios, including Universal City Studios, Warner Bros, and Netflix, instituted a commercial copyright suit before the Delhi High Court. The plaintiffs identified eighty-seven rogue websites engaged in unauthorized online streaming and downloading of copyrighted audiovisual catalogs. Despite substituted service through public notices and compliance orders, the website operators failed to appear or submit written statements. The plaintiffs moved an application under Order XIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking summary judgment and dynamic injunctive relief.

Issue

Can the High Court award summary judgment under Order XIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure against non-appearing rogue digital piracy platforms and issue dynamic blocking orders?

Ratio and Result

Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav granted summary judgment and decreed the suit in favor of the plaintiffs. The Court issued a permanent dynamic injunction against the eighty-seven rogue platforms and authorized the plaintiffs to notify mirror and redirect domains directly to regulatory authorities. The Department of Telecommunications and the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology were directed to enforce domain blocking orders. Read full analysis: Universal City Studios LLC & Ors. v. Dembed2.com & Ors. Case Analysis.

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

ABD Maestro Private Limited v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd., Delhi HC

What Happened

ABD Maestro Private Limited filed a commercial intellectual property suit before the Delhi High Court alleging trademark infringement of its registered alcoholic beverage brands. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant’s products sold in Madhya Pradesh infringed its marks and sought to establish territorial jurisdiction in Delhi under Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. The plaintiff relied upon a single trap purchase order placed through a digital portal by its representative from an address in New Delhi. The defendant filed an application under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenging the territorial jurisdiction of the Court.

Issue

Can an isolated, contrived trap order placed by a plaintiff’s agent confer territorial jurisdiction under Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 when the defendant conducts no commercial sales within the forum?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia allowed the application under Order VII Rule 10 and directed the return of the plaint for presentation before the competent court in Madhya Pradesh. The Court held that artificial trap orders cannot create a cause of action or establish forum jurisdiction. The Court ruled that Section 134(2) requires genuine commercial activity and cannot be invoked through engineered transactions. Read full analysis: ABD Maestro Private Limited v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd. Case Analysis.

K.A. Velayutham (Deceased) v. K.V. Vijayaraghavan (Deceased), Madras HC

What Happened

The legal representatives of deceased partners in the iconic Indian food brand Ambika Appalam Depot engaged in a protracted legal dispute before the Madras High Court concerning the partition of firm properties and trademarks. The plaintiffs sought partition of registered trademarks, trade names, and commercial properties based on an unacted private dissolution deed executed decades earlier. The defendants resisted the suit, establishing that the firm continued uninterrupted commercial operations, secured trademark registrations in the firm’s name, and maintained consolidated balance sheets.

Issue

Can registered trademarks and commercial assets belonging to a partnership firm be partitioned individually among legal heirs on the strength of a private dissolution deed that was never implemented?

Ratio and Result

Justice K. Kumaresh Babu dismissed the partition suit, holding that partnership assets and registered intellectual property belong to the firm as an indivisible commercial entity under Section 14 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932. The Court ruled that partners or their heirs possess no individual ownership in specific firm assets during the life of the partnership. The Court held that an unacted dissolution deed cannot dissolve statutory trademark rights held in the name of the firm. Read full analysis: K.A. Velayutham (Deceased) v. K.V. Vijayaraghavan (Deceased) Case Analysis.

The Aryan Educational Society v. Aaryan International School, Delhi HC

What Happened

The Aryan Educational Society had instituted a commercial trademark infringement suit before the Delhi High Court protecting its registered mark The Aryan School for educational services. The Court had previously passed an ex-parte decree on October 25, 2024, granting a permanent injunction and awarding five lakh rupees in damages against Aaryan International School. The defendant filed an application under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking to set aside the ex-parte decree, claiming that its former legal counsel had committed gross professional negligence by failing to appear in court.

Issue

Does professional negligence or non-appearance by engaged legal counsel constitute sufficient cause under Order IX Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure to vacate an ex-parte decree in a commercial suit?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia dismissed the application, holding that commercial litigants are under an active legal obligation to monitor court proceedings diligently. The Court observed that the defendant remained completely inactive for over two years and could not escape liability by shifting blame entirely onto former counsel. The Court upheld the permanent injunction and confirmed the damages decree. Read full analysis: The Aryan Educational Society v. Aaryan International School Case Analysis.

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Vikram Tea Processors Pvt. Ltd. v. Pannalal Tea Company, Bombay HC

What Happened

Vikram Tea Processors Pvt. Ltd. instituted a commercial intellectual property suit before the Bombay High Court against Pannalal Tea Company alleging trademark infringement and passing off in the FMCG sector. The plaintiff asserted statutory ownership over the registered trademark VIKRAM and distinctive yellow packaging trade dress for tea products in Class 30. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant manufactured and sold packet tea under a confusingly similar getup that misled consumers in rural markets. During interim proceedings, the parties engaged in formal settlement talks and executed comprehensive Consent Terms.

Issue

Can a contested trademark infringement and trade dress dispute be decreed under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure upon execution of reciprocal commercial settlement terms?

Ratio and Result

Justice Madhav J. Jamdar decreed the commercial suit in accordance with the signed Consent Terms. The defendant submitted to a permanent injunction, acknowledging the plaintiff’s proprietary trademark rights and agreeing never to use identical or deceptively similar packaging. The defendant also paid an agreed settlement sum and destroyed all remaining labels under the supervision of the plaintiff. Read full analysis: Vikram Tea Processors Pvt. Ltd. v. Pannalal Tea Company Case Analysis.

Sangeetha Caterers and Consultants LLP v. Grand Sangeetha Pure Veg, Madras HC

What Happened

Sangeetha Caterers and Consultants LLP filed a commercial suit before the Madras High Court alleging trademark infringement and passing off against a restaurant operating as Grand Sangeetha Pure Veg. The plaintiff established registered rights in the mark SANGEETHA across Classes 29, 30, and 43 for vegetarian restaurant and catering services dating back to 1979. The defendant adopted the name Grand Sangeetha Pure Veg for a restaurant in Tiruvannamalai, arguing that Sangeetha is a common Indian female personal name and represents classical musical art. The defendant failed to file a written statement after initial hearings.

Issue

Does the adoption of a prefix like Grand before an established restaurant trademark SANGEETHA avoid infringement under Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999?

Ratio and Result

Justice K. Kumaresh Babu decreed the commercial suit in favor of the plaintiff and granted a permanent injunction. The Court held that adding the laudatory word Grand does not eliminate the likelihood of confusion when the dominant commercial element SANGEETHA is identical. The defendant was ordered to pay nominal damages and remove all signage bearing the name within four weeks. Read full analysis: Sangeetha Caterers and Consultants LLP v. Grand Sangeetha Pure Veg Case Analysis.

Corona Remedies Limited v. Micro Labs Private Limited, Madras HC

What Happened

Corona Remedies Limited filed a rectification petition under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 before the Madras High Court seeking removal of the trademark CORTIL registered in the name of Micro Labs Private Limited. The petitioner claimed prior registration and use of the corporate mark CORONA for pharmaceutical goods in Class 5. The petitioner contended that the respondent’s mark CORTIL was deceptively similar, causing confusion among healthcare professionals and consumers. Micro Labs defended its registration, proving that CORTIL was derived from the active drug ingredient hydrocortisone and had been used continuously since 2004.

Issue

Can a pharmaceutical trademark derived from a chemical generic drug be cancelled under Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 on grounds of deceptive similarity with an earlier house mark?

Ratio and Result

Justice P.B. Balaji dismissed the rectification petition, holding that the marks CORONA and CORTIL are phonetically, visually, and structurally distinct. The Court noted that both marks had coexisted peacefully in the pharmaceutical market for over two decades without a single documented instance of consumer or clinician confusion. The Court confirmed that the registration of CORTIL remains valid on the Register. Read full analysis: Corona Remedies Limited v. Micro Labs Private Limited Case Analysis.

Arun Suradhan v. MPF Studios & Ors., Madras HC

What Happened

Screenwriter Arun Suradhan instituted a commercial copyright suit before the Madras High Court against film production house MPF Studios and its directors. The plaintiff claimed sole authorship of a dramatic screenplay and alleged that the defendants released a feature film based on his script without providing screen credit or agreed remuneration. The defendants demonstrated that the plaintiff had executed a comprehensive written assignment agreement and accepted monetary consideration, expressly assigning all intellectual property rights and moral claims in the script to the production company.

Issue

Does an author retain actionable copyright infringement claims against a film producer after executing a complete statutory assignment under Section 19 of the Copyright Act, 1957?

Ratio and Result

Justice K. Kumaresh Babu dismissed the copyright suit, holding that the plaintiff voluntarily divested himself of proprietary rights by signing the assignment contract. The Court held that under Section 19 of the Copyright Act, 1957, a valid assignment vests complete ownership in the assignee. The Court found no evidence of copyright infringement or breach of contract and dismissed the claim for damages. Read full analysis: Arun Suradhan v. MPF Studios & Ors. Case Analysis.

Healthium Medtech Limited v. The Registrar of Trade Marks, Madras HC

What Happened

Healthium Medtech Limited filed an appeal before the Intellectual Property Division of the Madras High Court challenging an administrative order passed by the Trade Marks Registry. The appellant had applied for registration of a specialized trademark covering medical and surgical devices in Class 10. The Registry rejected the application under Section 9 and Section 11 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 without addressing the detailed legal response submitted by the applicant. The appellant demonstrated that the hearing officer issued a computerized, single-line rejection order without affording a personal hearing.

Issue

Does an administrative refusal passed without recording legal reasons or providing a hearing violate principles of natural justice and Rule 33 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017?

Ratio and Result

Justice P.B. Balaji allowed the appeal, setting aside the rejection order passed by the Trade Marks Registry. The Court held that quasi-judicial authorities must record cogent grounds for rejecting statutory applications under Section 18(5). The Court remanded the file back to the Registry with directions to grant a personal hearing and decide the application on merits within three months. Read full analysis: Healthium Medtech Limited v. The Registrar of Trade Marks Case Analysis.

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Novex Communications Private Limited v. Campbell Resto and Lounge Bar LLP, Bombay HC

What Happened

Novex Communications Private Limited approached the Bombay High Court by filing a commercial copyright infringement suit against Campbell Resto and Lounge Bar LLP. The plaintiff held exclusive on-ground public performance rights in vast sound recording catalogs granted by major music labels, including Yash Raj Films and Zee Music. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant commercial lounge organized events and played protected musical tracks without obtaining a public performance license or paying tariff fees. Novex moved an interim application seeking an immediate injunction restraining public communication of its repertoire.

Issue

Does playing copyrighted sound recordings in commercial hospitality establishments without a public performance license constitute statutory infringement under Section 51 of the Copyright Act, 1957?

Ratio and Result

Justice Kamal Khata granted an ad-interim injunction restraining the lounge bar from playing or communicating any sound recordings from the plaintiff’s repertoire. The Court held that commercial enterprises cannot exploit creative musical works for profit without securing authorization and paying license fees. The defendant was directed to comply strictly with the licensing mandate. Read full analysis: Novex Communications Private Limited v. Campbell Resto and Lounge Bar LLP Case Analysis.

Ayra Decor v. RJ Enterprises, Bombay HC

What Happened

Ayra Decor instituted a commercial suit before the Bombay High Court against RJ Enterprises alleging copyright and trade dress infringement in decorative laminates and architectural surface designs. The plaintiff asserted copyright in original graphic textures and surface finishes marketed in its design catalogue. Ayra Decor alleged that the defendant manufactured and sold identical laminate sheets, causing customer confusion in the interior decor market. After interim orders were passed, the parties held settlement discussions and entered into mutually binding Consent Terms.

Issue

Can a dispute involving copyright and industrial trade dress in commercial design catalogues be settled through Consent Terms under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure?

Ratio and Result

Justice Madhav J. Jamdar accepted the Consent Terms and decreed the commercial suit accordingly. The defendant acknowledged the plaintiff’s exclusive rights, undertook to cease using the contested designs, and agreed to destroy remaining catalogues and sample folders. The Court ordered refund of court fees in accordance with High Court rules. Read full analysis: Ayra Decor v. RJ Enterprises Case Analysis.

Rupali Ganguly v. Huts and Looms Pvt. Ltd., Bombay HC

What Happened

Popular television actress Rupali Ganguly filed an interim application in a commercial intellectual property suit before the Bombay High Court against textile retailer Huts and Looms Pvt. Ltd. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant unauthorizedly used her photographs, promotional film stills, and personal likeness to advertise ethnic clothing on digital e-commerce channels. Ganguly asserted that her name, photographic likeness, and celebrity persona were commercially exploited without consent, causing false endorsement and damage to her commercial brand value.

Issue

Can a celebrity obtain an ad-interim injunction restraining commercial vendors from using photographs and persona attributes on digital platforms without authorization under common law personality rights?

Ratio and Result

Justice Kamal Khata granted an ad-interim injunction restraining the defendant and its affiliates from using the plaintiff’s name, photograph, voice, or likeness in any commercial advertisements. The Court held that celebrity persona and publicity rights cannot be appropriated for trade gain without an express commercial endorsement agreement. The defendant was directed to pull down all infringing social media posts within forty-eight hours. Read full analysis: Rupali Ganguly v. Huts and Looms Pvt. Ltd. Case Analysis.

V. Ramakrishnan v. The Registrar of Trade Marks, Madras HC

What Happened

V. Ramakrishnan preferred a statutory appeal before the Intellectual Property Division of the Madras High Court challenging the refusal of a trademark application by the Trade Marks Registry. The appellant applied for a composite label mark in Class 3 covering daily consumer preparations. The Examiner refused the mark under Section 11(1) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, citing registered marks that shared common descriptive words. The appellant demonstrated that the Registry had previously accepted identical marks for third parties in the same class, establishing inconsistent examination standards across the department.

Issue

Can the Trade Marks Registry apply contradictory prosecution standards to refuse an application under Section 11(1) while allowing identical marks to register in the same classification?

Ratio and Result

Justice P.B. Balaji set aside the administrative refusal order and remitted the matter for re-examination. The Court held that administrative bodies must maintain consistency and predictability in quasi-judicial determinations. The Court directed the Registry to advertise the mark in the Trade Marks Journal within three months if no subsisting conflicts are found. Read full analysis: V. Ramakrishnan v. The Registrar of Trade Marks Case Analysis.

Ananya Panday v. Fankaar Live Experiences Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., Bombay HC

What Happened

Film actress Ananya Panday approached the Bombay High Court filing a commercial suit against twenty-five named digital operators, domain hosts, and unknown John Doe defendants. The plaintiff alleged that rogue online entities used artificial intelligence algorithms to generate deepfake videos, digital voice clones, and sexually explicit depictions of her persona. The plaintiff also discovered counterfeit merchandise, mobile applications, and unauthorized fan clubs commercially exploiting her name and visual likeness without a licensing contract.

Issue

Is a celebrity entitled to omnibus dynamic injunctive relief against rogue platforms, AI deepfakes, and John Doe operators to protect personality and publicity rights?

Ratio and Result

Justice Kamal Khata granted an omnibus ad-interim injunction restraining all defendants from creating, uploading, circulating, or commercializing deepfakes or AI clones of the plaintiff. The Court ordered domain name registrars to suspend rogue website domains within twenty-four hours. Telecommunications authorities were directed to issue blocking orders to all internet service providers. Read full analysis: Ananya Panday v. Fankaar Live Experiences Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Case Analysis.

Amitabh Bachchan v. Rajat Nagi & Ors., Delhi HC

What Happened

Veteran actor Amitabh Bachchan had instituted a commercial intellectual property suit before the Delhi High Court in 2022 seeking protection for his name, photographic image, baritone voice, and persona. The suit impleaded multiple commercial vendors and John Doe entities operating fraudulent lottery schemes, artificial intelligence voice apps, and unapproved merchandise featuring his likeness. Following an earlier ex-parte injunction, the defendants chose not to contest the proceedings or file defense pleadings. The plaintiff moved for a final summary decree.

Issue

Can the High Court issue a permanent injunction and final decree safeguarding celebrity personality rights against non-appearing commercial infringers under Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia decreed the commercial suit in favor of the plaintiff and issued a permanent injunction. The Court held that an individual’s right to control the commercial exploitation of personality, voice, and likeness is protected under law. The Court restrained all defendants and John Does from using the actor’s persona attributes for trade or advertising without authorization. Read full analysis: Amitabh Bachchan v. Rajat Nagi & Ors. Case Analysis.

Friday, 6 November 2026

Jindal Composite Tubes Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Baldev Krishan & Anr., Delhi HC

What Happened

Jindal Composite Tubes Pvt. Ltd. and its holding company filed a commercial suit before the Delhi High Court against Baldev Krishan alleging trademark infringement and passing off. The plaintiffs asserted proprietary ownership over the well-known family of trademarks JINDAL registered in Class 17 and Class 19 for pipes and plumbing fittings. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants manufactured and marketed CPVC pipes under the mark GROJINDAL, copying their distinctive logo and packaging. The defendants challenged the territorial jurisdiction of the Court under Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

Issue

Can a corporate plaintiff invoke Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 to sue for infringement in Delhi when its subordinate corporate branch and registered office carry on business within the forum?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia granted an interim injunction restraining the defendants from using GROJINDAL or any mark containing the name JINDAL for pipes and building materials. The Court affirmed that the plaintiffs carry on substantial business in New Delhi, upholding territorial jurisdiction under Section 134(2). The Court held that adopting the prominent mark JINDAL with a descriptive prefix GRO constitutes deceptive similarity. Read full analysis: Jindal Composite Tubes Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Baldev Krishan & Anr. Case Analysis.

Voltas Limited v. Shiv Shakti Enterprises & Ors., Delhi HC

What Happened

Voltas Limited instituted a commercial trademark suit before the Delhi High Court against Shiv Shakti Enterprises and its partners. The defendants operated as former authorized customer service franchises for Voltas appliances. Following termination of their commercial agreement, the defendants continued using the registered mark VOLTAS on service uniforms, business letterheads, and unauthorized repair websites to solicit customers. Voltas filed an application under Order XIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking summary judgment and damages.

Issue

Can a trademark proprietor obtain summary judgment under Order XIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure and recover damages based on net profits from an ex-franchisee’s post-termination infringement?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia decreed the suit in favor of Voltas Limited and granted a permanent injunction. The Court awarded five lakh rupees in compensatory damages and five lakh seven thousand five hundred rupees in legal costs. The Court held that post-termination use of a well-known brand by an erstwhile franchisee is dishonest and damages brand equity. Read full analysis: Voltas Limited v. Shiv Shakti Enterprises & Ors. Case Analysis.

Educomp Solutions Limited v. B.D. Park & Ors. [Samsung], Delhi HC

What Happened

Educomp Solutions Limited instituted a commercial intellectual property suit before the Delhi High Court in 2017 against Samsung India Electronics Pvt. Ltd. and its corporate officers. The plaintiff asserted statutory rights in its composite trademark Educomp Smartclass and claimed that Samsung infringed its mark by marketing digital television screens under the term Smart Class. Samsung defended its commercial use under Section 30 and Section 35 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, asserting that smart class is a descriptive term denoting technology-enabled educational classrooms.

Issue

Does the registration of a composite trademark confer an exclusive monopoly over common descriptive words contained within the mark under Section 17 and Section 30 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia dismissed the suit, holding that the plaintiff possessed no exclusive right over the generic words smart class. The Court held that Educomp’s trademark registration was for a composite label and did not grant a monopoly over descriptive components. The Court ruled that Samsung used the term in good faith to describe product capabilities without causing consumer confusion. Read full analysis: Educomp Solutions Limited v. B.D. Park & Ors. Case Analysis.

Global Opportunities Pvt. Ltd. v. Ashwinee Satwe, Delhi HC

What Happened

Global Opportunities Pvt. Ltd. filed a commercial trademark suit before the Delhi High Court against overseas education consultant Ashwinee Satwe. The plaintiff held trademark registrations for GLOBAL OPPORTUNITIES in Class 41 and moved an interim injunction application to restrain the defendant from operating under the name GLOBAL STUDY EXPERT. The plaintiff contended that the word GLOBAL was the dominant and memorable feature of its brand. The defendant responded that GLOBAL is a common dictionary word widely used across the international education consultancy sector.

Issue

Can a service provider claim exclusive trademark rights over the generic word GLOBAL and restrain competitors from using it in descriptive composite trading styles under Section 17 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia dismissed the application for interim injunction, permitting the defendant to continue using GLOBAL STUDY EXPERT. The Court held that the word GLOBAL is descriptive, publici juris, and incapable of monopolization absent proof of distinct secondary meaning. The Court ruled that comparing the marks as a whole revealed no deceptive similarity. Read full analysis: Global Opportunities Pvt. Ltd. v. Ashwinee Satwe Case Analysis.

Hero Investcorp Private Limited & Anr. v. VM Lubricant, Delhi HC

What Happened

Hero Investcorp Private Limited and Hero MotoCorp Limited instituted a commercial suit before the Delhi High Court against VM Lubricant alleging trademark and trade dress infringement. The plaintiffs asserted proprietary ownership of the well-known mark HERO in Class 4 for automotive lubricants and engine oils. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendant manufactured and sold spurious automotive oils in packaging copying the distinctive HERO lettering and color scheme. The defendant failed to enter an appearance or file a written statement despite court summons.

Issue

Is a trademark owner entitled to a permanent injunction under Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure against an unrepresented counterfeiter imitating a well-known brand?

Ratio and Result

Justice Tejas Karia decreed the commercial suit in favor of the plaintiffs and issued a permanent injunction. The Court restrained VM Lubricant from manufacturing or marketing any lubricants bearing the mark HERO or confusingly similar packaging. The Court directed the defendant to deliver up all seized counterfeit oils and packaging materials for destruction. Read full analysis: Hero Investcorp Private Limited & Anr. v. VM Lubricant Case Analysis.

GI & Indian IP Registry News

Trade Marks Registry Launches Special Drive to Resolve Opposition Backlog Dating to 1944

The Office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks issued a public notice on 2 November 2026 announcing a special drive under the Swachhata Abhiyan initiative to clear long-pending opposition proceedings. The drive encompasses 23,282 opposition cases filed up to the year 2010 across the registry offices in Ahmedabad, Chennai, Delhi, Kolkata, and Mumbai, with the oldest pending matter dating back to September 1944. The registry scheduled these historical disputes for final hearings to eliminate administrative backlogs and improve procedural efficiency.

Because many pre-2010 records lack updated email addresses or digital contact details, the registry decided to conduct all hearings in physical mode at the respective jurisdictional offices. Individual hearing notices specifying dates, times, and benches are being dispatched by registered post to the recorded addresses for service. The Controller General established a strict adjournment policy prohibiting postponements except under exceptional circumstances, mandating that any rescheduled date cannot exceed seven days from the original hearing. Parties and agents attending the hearings must bring self-attested physical copies of original pleadings, powers of attorney, and evidentiary documents.

Kashi’s Sacred Ganga Soil Lakshmi-Ganesh Idols Await Final Geographical Indication Tag

The traditional stick-on Lakshmi-Ganesh idols of Varanasi, sculpted using sacred soil from the River Ganga, are awaiting final registration after the Geographical Indications Registry completed formal hearings on the Banaras Clay Craft application. The craft, practiced by Prajapati potter families in Laxmikund and surrounding localities, involves shaping river silt, firing the idols in traditional kilns, hand-painting the figures, and attaching decorative spokes to form an ornate crown. The idols hold deep spiritual significance during Diwali, when devotees install them in homes and businesses to pray for prosperity.

Padma Shri recipient Dr. Rajnikant, who facilitated the application, stated that Geographical Indication registration will protect the craft against commercial imitations and create structured market access for local artisans. The artwork reflects historical cultural ties between Varanasi and Maharashtra, connecting with the Peshwa family’s religious observances in the city and public Ganeshotsav celebrations organized at Brahmaghat since 1898. Certified registration is expected to protect traditional artisanal techniques and expand distribution to national markets and overseas Indian communities.

ASSOCHAM Conclave Promotes Commercial Market Linkages for Goa’s Geographical Indications

The ASSOCHAM Goa State Council organized a state conclave on Geographical Indications in Panaji to strengthen commercial channels and brand protection for local agricultural and artisanal products. Organized with knowledge partner Resolute4IP, the event featured the release of a coffee table book documenting Goa’s registered geographical indications. Goa Agriculture Secretary Nikhil Desai announced during the conclave that the state government will establish a specialized pack house and agricultural logistics facility at Mopa Airport in December 2026 to improve produce handling and support export shipments for local growers.

Industry stakeholders focused on creating direct commercial links between farmers and the hospitality sector to curb counterfeit marketing and build reliable demand. Representatives from the Travel and Tourism Association of Goa and the National Restaurant Association of India presented Letters of Intent to the Directorate of Agriculture supporting the GOA FRESH program, an initiative under the Swayampurna Goa framework. The initiative seeks to connect hotels and restaurants directly with producers of certified products, including cashew feni, bebinca, and five agricultural items recognized in 2026, comprising Goa cashew apple, Mussarad mango, Hilario mango, Khorgut rice, and Taleigao brinjal.

The district administration of Ratlam in Madhya Pradesh initiated strict enforcement measures to protect the integrity of the registered Geographical Indication tag for Ratlami Sev. Ratlam District Collector Ajay Katesaria directed authorities during a joint meeting of the Small Industries Promotion Board and the Export Promotion Board to issue formal notices against unregistered manufacturers selling snack foods under the protected name. The administration instructed officials to prepare compensation claims against businesses that misuse the designation without holding statutory authorized user status.

District officials affirmed that the statutory protection guarantees that only registered producers adhering to traditional manufacturing standards can trade under the Ratlami Sev mark. To support authorized commercial producers and broaden regional distribution, the collector directed the industries department to coordinate with the Divisional Railway Manager of Western Railway to introduce certified Ratlami Sev at railway station food stalls and add the product to official train catering menus.

ICAR-CIFT Partners with Andaman Administration to Secure GI Protection for Indigenous Fish Products

The ICAR-Central Institute of Fisheries Technology in Kochi entered into a formal technical agreement with the Department of Fisheries under the Andaman and Nicobar Administration to secure Geographical Indication registration for two traditional island fish products. The collaboration focuses on securing statutory protection for Chilled Andaman Coral Trout, known commercially as Dollar Fish, and Nicobari Thoharango, an indigenous smoked and dried fish delicacy prepared using traditional tribal methods in the Nicobar archipelago.

Under the agreement, ICAR-CIFT will undertake comprehensive nutritional profiling and biochemical characterization to document the distinct regional qualities of both marine products. The institute will also establish standardized hygienic processing protocols and provide technical training to local tribal and artisanal fishing communities. The initiative aims to protect regional heritage against unauthorized commercial use while opening verified commercial supply chains for island fishermen.

Key Precedents & Statutory Guidance

International IP Updates

The New York Times, joined by the New York Daily News, Chicago Tribune, and Orlando Sentinel, filed a federal copyright infringement lawsuit against Brave Software in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. The publishers allege that Brave operates its web crawler to scrape copyrighted news articles without permission or licensing agreements. According to the complaint, Brave compiles this scraped material into its proprietary Brave Search Index and sells commercial access to artificial intelligence companies, including Anthropic and Mistral, for model training and real-time query retrieval.

The complaint asserts claims for direct and secondary copyright infringement, alongside violations of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The publishers allege that Brave’s artificial intelligence assistant, Leo, reproduces text excerpts and detailed summaries of protected articles without subscription credentials. The lawsuit also targets Brave’s built-in paywall bypass tools, alleging that the browser actively circumvents technical access barriers designed to protect subscription-based reporting. The publishers are seeking statutory damages and permanent injunctive relief to halt unauthorized indexing.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit ruled that a law firm’s use of artificial intelligence tools does not justify an automatic reduction in court-awarded attorney fees. In Flux Drive Inc. v. Rong, a unanimous three-judge panel affirmed a defense fee award exceeding 114,000 dollars following the dismissal of trade secret misappropriation claims. The losing plaintiffs challenged the award by arguing that defense counsel should have billed fewer hours because the attorneys used artificial intelligence programs and digital research tools to prepare their filings.

Writing for the court, Circuit Judge Carolyn McHugh acknowledged that modern technological tools can increase research speed, but held that the mere use of artificial intelligence does not demonstrate that billed hours were excessive. The appellate court established that a party challenging an attorney fee award retains the affirmative burden of proving that specific hours were unreasonable or that actual billing inflation occurred. The decision establishes an important federal precedent protecting legitimate fee recovery as legal practices integrate automated research technology.

Advocate General Maciej Szpunar of the Court of Justice of the European Union issued a formal advisory opinion stating that artificial intelligence chatbots may violate press publishers’ copyrights when generating responses to user queries. The opinion arose from Hungarian litigation brought by media company Like Company against Google concerning the Gemini conversational platform. The proceeding represents the first generative artificial intelligence copyright dispute considered by the European Union’s highest judicial authority.

The Advocate General drew a distinction between model training and public-facing outputs. The opinion noted that ingesting published journalism to train artificial intelligence models falls under the statutory text and data mining exceptions of European Union copyright directives. However, the adviser concluded that chatbots violate publishers’ exclusive reproduction rights if the tools bypass technical paywalls or reproduce the protected original expression of news articles rather than uncopyrightable factual information. While non-binding, the opinion provides guidance for the full court’s upcoming final ruling.

Pentagon Chief Technology Officer Announces Federal Guidance Mapping Existing Laws for AI Laboratories

Pentagon Chief Technology Officer Emil Michael announced that the United States federal government will release a comprehensive compendium detailing all existing statutory and administrative laws that apply to domestic artificial intelligence developers. Speaking at a Wall Street Journal technology conference in Napa, California, Michael stated that the administration’s Super Intelligence Task Force will publish the compliance framework to clarify legal obligations across the sector. Michael serves as the vice chair of the intergovernmental task force.

Michael explained that outlining how current federal regulations apply to artificial intelligence operations will give laboratories clear guidance and strengthen public confidence. The technology chief warned that without clear administrative guidance on existing legal standards, the industry risks facing uncoordinated statutory measures from individual lawmakers that could harm domestic technological progress. The published framework is scheduled for public release in mid-November.

Written by

Adv. Koushik Chittella

IP Law Practitioner

Indian IP Law Trademark Patent Copyright

An Advocate enrolled on the rolls of the Bar Council of the State of Andhra Pradesh. What started as curiosity about how the law protects ideas, brands, inventions, and creative works gradually developed into a genuine passion for studying and explaining IP law, inspiring me to pursue a Masters degree (LL.M.) in Intellectual Property Rights (IPR).